The unique synaptic circuitry of specialized olfactory glomeruli in Drosophila melanogaster
Curation statements for this article:-
Curated by eLife
eLife assessment
This study seeks to determine how synaptic relationships between principal cell types in the olfactory system vary with glomerulus selectivity and is therefore valuable to the sub-field. The methodology is solid, but technical limitations require that claims regarding local interneurons be tempered as they were grouped with other neuron types for analyses, and with only one sample from each glomerulus, it is difficult to assess the import of differences between glomeruli without measures of inter-animal variability.
This article has been Reviewed by the following groups
Listed in
- Evaluated articles (eLife)
- Evaluated articles (preLights)
- Neuroscience (eLife)
- Multiple group peer review and curation (scietyHQ)
Abstract
In the Drosophila olfactory system most odorants are encoded in the antennal lobe in a combinatory way, activating several glomerular circuits. However, odorants of particular ecological role for the fly are encoded through activation of a single specialized olfactory pathway. Comparative analyses of densely reconstructed connectomes of one broadly tuned glomerulus (DL5) and one narrowly tuned glomerulus (DA2) gained detailed insight into the variations of synaptic circuitries of glomeruli with different computational tasks. Our approach combined laser-branding of glomeruli of interest with volume based focused ion beam-scanning electron microscopy (FIB-SEM) to enable precise targeting and analysis of the two glomeruli. We discovered differences in their neuronal innervation, synaptic composition and specific circuit diagrams of their major cell types: olfactory sensory neurons (OSNs), uniglomerular projection neurons (uPNs) and multiglomerular neurons (MGNs). By comparing our data with a previously mapped narrowly tuned glomerulus (VA1v), we identified putative generic features of narrowly tuned glomerular circuits, including higher density of neuronal fibers and synapses, lower degree of OSN lateralization, stronger axo-axonic connections between OSNs, dendro-dendritic connections between many uPNs, and lower degree of presynaptic inhibition on OSN axons. In addition, this work revealed that the dendrites of the single uPN in DL5 contain a substantial amount of autapses interconnecting distant regions of the dendritic tree. The comparative analysis of glomeruli allows to formulate synaptic motifs implemented in olfactory circuits with different computational demands.
Article activity feed
-
-
-
eLife assessment
This study seeks to determine how synaptic relationships between principal cell types in the olfactory system vary with glomerulus selectivity and is therefore valuable to the sub-field. The methodology is solid, but technical limitations require that claims regarding local interneurons be tempered as they were grouped with other neuron types for analyses, and with only one sample from each glomerulus, it is difficult to assess the import of differences between glomeruli without measures of inter-animal variability.
-
Reviewer #1 (Public Review):
In this manuscript, Gruber et al perform serial EM sections of the antennal lobe and reconstruct the neurites innervating two types of glomeruli - one that is narrowly tuned to geosmin and one that is broadly tuned to other odours. They quantify and describe various aspects of the innervations of olfactory sensory neurons (OSNs), uniglomerlular projection neurons (uPNs), and the multiglomerular Local interneurons (LNs) and PNs (mPNs). They find that narrowly tuned glomeruli had stronger connectivity from OSNs to PNs and LNs, and considerably more connections between sister OSNs and sister PNs than the broadly tuned glomeruli. They also had less connectivity with the contralateral glomerluli. These observations are suggestive of strong feed-forward information flow with minimal presynaptic inhibition in …
Reviewer #1 (Public Review):
In this manuscript, Gruber et al perform serial EM sections of the antennal lobe and reconstruct the neurites innervating two types of glomeruli - one that is narrowly tuned to geosmin and one that is broadly tuned to other odours. They quantify and describe various aspects of the innervations of olfactory sensory neurons (OSNs), uniglomerlular projection neurons (uPNs), and the multiglomerular Local interneurons (LNs) and PNs (mPNs). They find that narrowly tuned glomeruli had stronger connectivity from OSNs to PNs and LNs, and considerably more connections between sister OSNs and sister PNs than the broadly tuned glomeruli. They also had less connectivity with the contralateral glomerluli. These observations are suggestive of strong feed-forward information flow with minimal presynaptic inhibition in narrowly tuned gomeruli, which might be ecologically relevant, for example, while making quick decisions such as avoiding a geosmin-laden landing site. In contrast, information flow in more broadly tuned glomeruli show much more lateralisation of connectivity to the contralateral glomerulus, as well as to other ipsilateral glomeruli.
The data are well presented, the manuscript clearly written, and the results will be useful to the olfaction community. I wonder, given the hemibrain and FAFB datasets exist, whether the authors have considered verifying whether the trends they observe in connectivity hold across three brains? Is it stereotypic?
-
Reviewer #2 (Public Review):
The chemoreceptor proteins expressed by olfactory sensory neurons differ in their selectivity such that glomeruli vary in the breadth of volatile chemicals to which they respond. Prior work assessing the relationship between tuning breadth and the demographics of principal neuron types that innervate a glomerulus demonstrated that narrowly tuned glomeruli are innervated more projection neurons (output neurons) and fewer local interneurons relative to more broadly tuned glomeruli. The present study used high-resolution electron microscopy to determine which synaptic relationships between principal cell types also vary with glomerulus tuning breadth using a narrowly tuned glomerulus (DA2) and a broadly tuned glomerulus (DL5). The strength of this study lies in the comprehensive, synapse-level resolution of the …
Reviewer #2 (Public Review):
The chemoreceptor proteins expressed by olfactory sensory neurons differ in their selectivity such that glomeruli vary in the breadth of volatile chemicals to which they respond. Prior work assessing the relationship between tuning breadth and the demographics of principal neuron types that innervate a glomerulus demonstrated that narrowly tuned glomeruli are innervated more projection neurons (output neurons) and fewer local interneurons relative to more broadly tuned glomeruli. The present study used high-resolution electron microscopy to determine which synaptic relationships between principal cell types also vary with glomerulus tuning breadth using a narrowly tuned glomerulus (DA2) and a broadly tuned glomerulus (DL5). The strength of this study lies in the comprehensive, synapse-level resolution of the approach. Furthermore, the authors implement a very elegant approach of using a 2-photon microscope to score the upper and lower bounds of each glomerulus, thus defining the bounds of their restricted regions of interest. There were several interesting differences including greater axo-axonic afferent synapses and dendrodentric output neuron synapses in the narrowly tuned glomerulus, and greater synapses upon sensory afferents from multiglomerular neurons and output neuron autapses in the broadly tuned glomerulus.
The study is limited by a few factors. There was a technical need to group all local interneurons, centrifugal neurons, and multiglomerular projection neurons into one category ("multiglomerular neurons") which complicates any interpretations as even multiglomerular projection neurons are very diverse. Additionally, there were as many differences between the two narrowly tuned glomeruli as there were comparing the narrowly and broadly tuned glomeruli. Architecture differences may therefore not reflect differences in tuning breadth, but rather the ecological significance of the odors detected by cognate sensory afferents. Finally, some synaptic relationships are described as differing and others as being the same between glomeruli, but with only one sample from each glomerulus, it is difficult to determine when measures differ when there is no measure of inter-animal variability. If these caveats are kept in mind, this work reveals some very interesting potential differences in circuit architecture associated with glomerular tuning breadth.
This work establishes specific hypotheses about network function within the olfactory system that can be pursued using targeted physiological approaches. It also identifies key traits that can be explored using other high-resolution EM datasets and other glomeruli that vary in their tuning selectivity. Finally, the laser "branding" technique used in this study establishes a reduced-cost procedure for obtaining smaller EM datasets from targeted volumes of interest by leveraging the ability to transgenically label brain regions in Drosophila.
-
Excerpt
Ever tried untangling a plate of pasta? This preprint tries to make sense of the spaghetti-like connections of narrowly and broadly tuned olfactory glomeruli in the Drosophila brain.
-
-
-