Characterization and modulation of human insulin degrading enzyme conformational dynamics to control enzyme activity
Curation statements for this article:-
Curated by eLife
eLife Assessment
The manuscript by Mancl et al. provides important mechanistic insights into the conformational dynamics of Insulin Degrading Enzyme (IDE), a zinc metalloprotease involved in the clearance of amyloid peptides. In the revised version, the authors have substantially expanded their analysis by incorporating time-resolved cryo-EM and coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulations, which reveal an insulin-induced allosteric transition and transient β-sheet interactions underlying IDE's unfoldase activity. Supported by a convincing combination of cryo-EM, SEC-SAXS, enzymatic assays, and both all-atom and coarse-grained simulations, this work refines our understanding of IDE's functional cycle and offers a structural framework for developing substrate-selective modulators of M16 metalloproteases.
This article has been Reviewed by the following groups
Discuss this preprint
Start a discussion What are Sciety discussions?Listed in
- Evaluated articles (eLife)
Abstract
Insulin degrading enzyme (IDE) is a dimeric M16A zinc metalloprotease that degrades amyloidogenic peptides diverse in shape and sequence, including insulin and amyloid-β, to prevent toxic amyloid fibril formation. IDE has a hollow catalytic chamber formed by two ∼55 kDa N- and C-domains (IDE-N and IDE-C, respectively), in which peptides bind, unfold, and are repositioned for proteolysis. IDE is known to transition between a closed state, poised for catalysis, and an open state, able to release cleavage products and bind new substrate. Here, we present five cryo-EM structures of the IDE dimer at 3.0-4.1 Å resolution, obtained in the presence of a sub-saturating concentration of insulin. Combining cryo-EM heterogeneity analysis with all-atom molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, we identified the structural basis and key residues for IDE conformational dynamics that were not revealed by IDE static structures. Notably R668 serves as a molecular latch mediating the open-close transition and facilitates key protein motions through charge-swapping interactions at the IDE-N/C interface. Our small-angle X-ray scattering and enzymatic assays of an R668A mutant indicate a profound alteration of conformational dynamics and catalytic activity. By integrating coarse-grained Upside MD simulations, our analysis reveals that IDE unfolds its substrates through the coordinated motion between IDE-N and IDE-C, as well as β-sheet formation between IDE and insulin. Additionally, our time-resolved cryo-EM analysis uncovers IDE allostery within the IDE dimer. Collectively, our findings demonstrate the strength of combining experimental and computational approaches to probe protein dynamics and pave the way for developing substrate-specific modulators of IDE activity.
Article activity feed
-
-
-
eLife Assessment
The manuscript by Mancl et al. provides important mechanistic insights into the conformational dynamics of Insulin Degrading Enzyme (IDE), a zinc metalloprotease involved in the clearance of amyloid peptides. In the revised version, the authors have substantially expanded their analysis by incorporating time-resolved cryo-EM and coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulations, which reveal an insulin-induced allosteric transition and transient β-sheet interactions underlying IDE's unfoldase activity. Supported by a convincing combination of cryo-EM, SEC-SAXS, enzymatic assays, and both all-atom and coarse-grained simulations, this work refines our understanding of IDE's functional cycle and offers a structural framework for developing substrate-selective modulators of M16 metalloproteases.
-
Reviewer #1 (Public review):
Summary:
Mancl et al. present a comprehensive integrative study combining cryo-EM, SAXS, enzymatic assays, and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to characterize conformational dynamics of human insulin-degrading enzyme (IDE). In the revised manuscript, the study now also includes time-resolved cryo-EM and coarse-grained MD simulations, which strengthen the mechanistic model by revealing insulin-induced allostery and β-sheet interactions between IDE and insulin. Together, these results expand the original mechanistic insight and further validate R668 as a key residue governing the open-close transition and substrate-dependent activity modulation of IDE.
Strengths:
The authors have substantially expanded the experimental scope by adding time-resolved cryo-EM data and coarse-grained MD simulations, directly …
Reviewer #1 (Public review):
Summary:
Mancl et al. present a comprehensive integrative study combining cryo-EM, SAXS, enzymatic assays, and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to characterize conformational dynamics of human insulin-degrading enzyme (IDE). In the revised manuscript, the study now also includes time-resolved cryo-EM and coarse-grained MD simulations, which strengthen the mechanistic model by revealing insulin-induced allostery and β-sheet interactions between IDE and insulin. Together, these results expand the original mechanistic insight and further validate R668 as a key residue governing the open-close transition and substrate-dependent activity modulation of IDE.
Strengths:
The authors have substantially expanded the experimental scope by adding time-resolved cryo-EM data and coarse-grained MD simulations, directly addressing requests for mechanistic depth and temporal insight. The integration of multiple resolution scales (cryo-EM heterogeneity analysis, all-atom and coarse-grained MD simulations, and biochemical validation) now provides a coherent description of the conformational transitions and allosteric regulation of IDE. The addition of Aβ degradation assays strengthens the claim that R668 modulates IDE function in a substrate-specific manner. Finally, the manuscript reads more clearly: figure organization, section headers, and inclusion of a new introductory figure make it accessible to a broader audience. Overall, the revision reinforces the conceptual advance that the dynamic interdomain motions of IDE underlie both its unfoldase and protease activities and identifies structural motifs that could be targeted pharmacologically.
Weaknesses:
While the authors acknowledge that future studies on additional IDE substrates (e.g., amylin and glucagon) are warranted, such experiments remain outside the present scope. Their absence modestly limits the generalization of the R668 mechanism across all IDE substrates. Despite improved discussion of kinetic timescales and enzyme-substrate interactions, experimental correlation between MD timescales and catalysis remains primarily inferential. The moderate local resolution of some cryo-EM states (notably O/pO) continues to limit atomic interpretation of the most flexible regions, though the authors address this carefully.
-
Reviewer #2 (Public review):
Summary:
The manuscript describes various conformational states and structural dynamics of the Insulin degrading enzyme (IDE), a zinc metalloprotease by nature. Both open and closed state structures of IDE have been previously solved using crystallography and cryo-EM which reveal a dimeric organization of IDE where each monomer is organized into N and C domains. C-domains form the interacting interface in the dimeric protein while the two N-domains are positioned on the outer sides of the core formed by C-domains. It remains elusive how the open state is converted into the closed state but it is generally accepted that it involves large-scale movement of N-domains relative to the C-domains. Authors here have used various complementary experimental techniques such as cryo-EM, SAXS, size-exclusion …
Reviewer #2 (Public review):
Summary:
The manuscript describes various conformational states and structural dynamics of the Insulin degrading enzyme (IDE), a zinc metalloprotease by nature. Both open and closed state structures of IDE have been previously solved using crystallography and cryo-EM which reveal a dimeric organization of IDE where each monomer is organized into N and C domains. C-domains form the interacting interface in the dimeric protein while the two N-domains are positioned on the outer sides of the core formed by C-domains. It remains elusive how the open state is converted into the closed state but it is generally accepted that it involves large-scale movement of N-domains relative to the C-domains. Authors here have used various complementary experimental techniques such as cryo-EM, SAXS, size-exclusion chromatography and enzymatic assays to characterize the structure and dynamics of IDE protein in the presence of substrate protein insulin whose density is captured in all the structures solved. The experimental structural data from cryo-EM suffered from high degree of intrinsic motion amongst the different domains and consequently, the resultant structures were moderately resolved at 3-4.1 Å resolution. Total five structures were generated in the originally submitted manuscript using cryo-EM. Another cryo-EM reconstruction (sixth) at 5.1Å resolution was mentioned after first revision which was obtained using time-resolved cryo-EM experiments. Authors have extensively used Molecular dynamics simulation to fish out important inter-subunit contacts which involves R668, E381, D309, etc residues. In summary, authors have explored the conformational dynamics of IDE protein using experimental approaches which are complimented and analyzed in atomic details by using MD simulation studies. The studies are meticulously conducted and lay ground for future exploration of protease structure-function relationship.
Comments after first peer-review:
The authors have addressed all my concerns, and have added new data and explanations in terms of time-resolved cryo-EM (Fig. 7) and upside simulations (Fig. 8) which in my opinion have strengthened the merit of the manuscript.
-
Author response:
The following is the authors’ response to the original reviews.
Reviewer #1 (Public review):
Summary:
Mancl et al. present cryo-EM structures of the Insulin Degrading Enzyme (IDE) dimer and characterize its conformational dynamics by integrating structures with SEC-SAXS, enzymatic activity assays, and all-atom molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. They present five cryo-EM structures of the IDE dimer at 3.0-4.1 Å resolution, obtained with one of its substrates, insulin, added to IDE in a 1:2 ratio. The study identified R668 as a key residue mediating the open-close transition of IDE, a finding supported by simulations and experimental data. The work offers a refined model for how IDE recognizes and degrades amyloid peptides, incorporating the roles of IDE-N rotation and charge-swapping events at the IDE-N/C interface.
St…
Author response:
The following is the authors’ response to the original reviews.
Reviewer #1 (Public review):
Summary:
Mancl et al. present cryo-EM structures of the Insulin Degrading Enzyme (IDE) dimer and characterize its conformational dynamics by integrating structures with SEC-SAXS, enzymatic activity assays, and all-atom molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. They present five cryo-EM structures of the IDE dimer at 3.0-4.1 Å resolution, obtained with one of its substrates, insulin, added to IDE in a 1:2 ratio. The study identified R668 as a key residue mediating the open-close transition of IDE, a finding supported by simulations and experimental data. The work offers a refined model for how IDE recognizes and degrades amyloid peptides, incorporating the roles of IDE-N rotation and charge-swapping events at the IDE-N/C interface.
Strengths:
The study by Mancl et al. uses a combination of experimental (cryoEM, SEC-SAXS, enzymatic assays) and computational (MD simulations, multibody analysis, 3DVA) techniques to provide a comprehensive characterization of IDE dynamics. The identification of R668 as a key residue mediating the open-to-close transition of IDE is a novel finding, supported by both simulations and experimental data presented in the manuscript. The work offers a refined model for how IDE recognizes and degrades amyloid peptides, incorporating the roles of IDE-N rotation and chargeswapping events at the IDE-N/C interface. The study identifies the structural basis and key residues for IDE dynamics that were not revealed by static structures.
Weaknesses:
Based on MD simulations and enzymatic assays of IDE, the authors claim that the R668A mutation in IDE affects the conformational dynamics governing the open-closed transition, which leads to altered substrate binding and catalysis. The functional importance of R668 would be substantiated by enzymatic assays that included some of the other known substrates of IDE than insulin such as amylin and glucagon.
We have included amyloid beta in our enzymatic assays, as shown in Figure 5D, and have updated the manuscript text accordingly. The R668A mutation results in a loss of dose-dependent competition with amyloid beta, but not with insulin. To further substantiate this unexpected finding, we plan to undertake a comprehensive biochemical characterization of the R668A mutation across a variety of substrates, followed by structural analysis of this mutant. However, these investigations are beyond the scope of the current study and, if successful, warrant a separate publication.
It is unclear to what extent the force field (FF) employed in the MD simulations favors secondary structures and if the lack of any observed structural changes within the IDE domains in the simulations - which is taken to suggest that the domains behave as rigid bodies - stems from bias by the FF.
We utilized the widely adopted CHARMM36 force field, whose parameters have been validated by thousands of previous studies. As shown in Figure 2A, our simulations reveal small but noticeable fluctuations in intradomain RMSD values. However, after careful examination, we found that these changes do not correspond to any biologically meaningful motions based on previously reported structural and biophysical characterizations of IDE (e.g., Shen et al., Nature 2006; Noinaj et al., PLOS One 2011; McCord et al., PNAS 2013; Zhang et al., eLife 2018, and references therein).
Reviewer #2 (Public review):
Summary:
The manuscript describes various conformational states and structural dynamics of the Insulin degrading enzyme (IDE), a zinc metalloprotease by nature. Both open and closed-state structures of IDE have been previously solved using crystallography and cryo-EM which reveal a dimeric organization of IDE where each monomer is organized into N and C domains. C-domains form the interacting interface in the dimeric protein while the two N-domains are positioned on the outer sides of the core formed by Cdomains. It remains elusive how the open state is converted into the closed state but it is generally accepted that it involves large-scale movement of N-domains relative to the C-domains. The authors here have used various complementary experimental techniques such as cryo-EM, SAXS, size-exclusion chromatography, and enzymatic assays to characterize the structure and dynamics of IDE protein in the presence of substrate protein insulin whose density is captured in all the structures solved. The experimental structural data from cryo-EM suffered from a high degree of intrinsic motion among the different domains and consequently, the resultant structures were moderately resolved at 3-4.1 Å resolution. A total of five structures were generated by cryo-EM. The authors have extensively used Molecular dynamics simulation to fish out important inter-subunit contacts which involve R668, E381, D309, etc residues. In summary, authors have explored the conformational dynamics of IDE protein using experimental approaches which are complemented and analyzed in atomic details by using MD simulation studies. The studies are meticulously conducted and lay the ground for future exploration of the protease structure-function relationship.
Reviewer #1 (Recommendations for the authors):
The manuscript reads well, however, there are minor details throughout that would tighten it up and, in some cases, make it easier to approach for a broader readership:
Abstract
(1) R668 is referred to by its one-letter code throughout the main text but referred to as arginine-668 in the abstract. The abstract should be corrected to R668.
This has been corrected.
(2) The authors should consider reordering the significance of their work as it is listed at the end of the abstract. As the work first and foremost "offers the molecular basis of unfoldase activity of IDE and provides a new path forward towards the development of substrate-specific modulators of IDE activity" these should come before "the power of integrating experimental and computational methodologies to understand protein dynamics".
We have revised abstract substantially to incorporate the new findings. Consequently, the sentence for "the power of integrating experimental and computational methodologies to understand protein dynamics" has been removed.
Main text
(1) Cryo-EM is consistently referred to as cryoEM throughout the text. The commonly accepted format for referring to cryogenic electron microscopy is cryo-EM. The authors are asked to consider revising the text accordingly.
The text has been revised.
(2) Introduction: The authors are asked to consider including a figure (panel) that provides the general reader with an overview of IDE architecture and topology as a point of reference in the introduction to understanding the pseudo symmetry in IDE, domains, and IDE-C relative to IDE-N, etc. This is relevant for reading most of the figures.
We have added a new figure 1 to provide the background and questions to be answered.
(3) The authors should consider renaming some of the headers in the results section to include the main conclusion. For instance, "CryoEM structures of IDE in the presence of a sub-saturating concentration of insulin" is not really helpful for the reader to understand the work, while "R668A mediates IDE conformational dynamics in vitro" is.
The headings have been altered in an effort to be more informative.
(4) It is unclear what the timescale for insulin cleavage is for IDE. Clearly, it is possible for the authors to capture an insulin-bound IDE from within the 7 million particles, but what is the chance of this? The authors emphasize the IDE:insulin ratio relative to previous experiments, but surely the kinetics would be the same in the two experiments that were presumably set up exactly the same way. In the context of this, the authors should disclose how concentrations were estimated experimentally. The authors are encouraged to touch upon the subject of time scales to tie up cryo-EM and enzyme experiments with MD simulations.
Both reviewers posted the question about time-scale relevant to IDE catalysis. In response to this request, we have revised the manuscript to address the relevance of key kinetic timescales. Specifically, we now discuss the open/closed transition (~0.1 second) and insulin cleavage (~2/sec), both established experimentally in prior studies (McCord et al PNAS 2013).
IDE concentrations were determined by spectrometry (Nanodrop and/or Bradford assay), and its purity was confirmed to be greater than 90% by SDS-PAGE. Insulin was purchased commercially, weighed, and dissolved in buffer, with its concentration subsequently verified using Nanodrop. Catalytically inactive IDE and insulin were mixed and incubated for at least 30 minutes. Given IDE’s low nanomolar affinity for insulin, and the sub-stoichiometric insulin concentrations used, sufficient time was allowed for insulin to bind IDE and remain bound.
To distinguish between IDE’s unfoldase and protease activities, all structural analyses were performed in the presence of EDTA, which chelates catalytic zinc, thereby inactivating IDE. This approach inhibits the enzyme’s catalytic cycle and allows us to capture the fully unfolded state of insulin bound to IDE in its closed conformation, representing the endpoint of the reaction. Under these conditions, the only meaningful kinetic parameter available for investigation was the unfolding of insulin by IDE.
To elaborate the interaction between IDE and insulin in the catalytically relevant time regime, we investigated IDE–insulin interactions within the millisecond time regime by rapidly mixing IDE with a large molar excess of insulin for approximately 120 milliseconds for the cryo-EM single particle analysis. Under these conditions, we observed that both IDE subunits in the dimer predominantly adopt open states, which are distinct from those previously reported. This observation suggests a potential mechanism of allostery in IDE function.
(5) It should be included in the main text that the data was processed with C1 symmetry and not just in Table 1. This is more useful information for understanding the study than the number of micrographs.
We have stated that the data was processed with C1 symmetry at the start of the results section.
(6) The authors should consider adding speculation on what the approximately 6 million particles that did not yield a high-resolution structure represent.
In cryo-EM single particle analysis, particle selection is typically performed automatically using software such as Relion. Due to the low signal-to-noise ratio, many “junk particles”—originating from contaminants such as ice, impurities, aggregates, or incomplete particles—are inevitably included along with the particles of interest. It is standard practice to filter out these junk particles during data processing. In our case, we estimate that the majority of the 6 million particles are likely junk. However, we cannot fully exclude the possibility that some of these particles may originate from IDE and carry potentially useful information about its conformational heterogeneity. Nonetheless, current cryo-EM single particle analysis methods face significant challenges in objectively recovering and interpreting such particles.
Reviewer #2 (Recommendations for the authors):
I have some minor comments regarding the manuscript which are given below.
(1) For O/O state, it will be great to see an explanation regarding why the values are dissimilar for 0.5 and 0.143 FSC.
All of our IDE structures (including previously published data) demonstrate a dip/plateau at moderate resolution in their FSCs. We interpret this an indicator of structural heterogeneity, as the dip/plateau is smallest in the pC/pC state, becomes larger when one of the subunits is open, and is largest when both subunits are open. Because both subunits within the O/O state are highly heterogeneous, the FSC dipped below the 0.5 threshold. Other states, such as the O/pO, display the same FSC trend, the dip remains slightly above the 0.5 threshold.
(2) O/pO state is moderately resolved at 4.1 Å, but this state is populated with many particles (328,870). Can the resolution be improved by more extensive sorting of heterogenous particles which intrinsically causes misalignment amongst particles?
Unfortunately, no. As shown by the local resolution maps in Figure 1-figure supplement 1, the primary source of misalignment is the IDE-N region in the open subunit. We have found that IDE-N is nearly unconstrained in its conformational flexibility in the open state, and does not appear to adopt discrete states, our attempts to better classify particles have failed. We speculate that this may be a failing in kmeans cluster based classification, and this is part of the driving force behind our exploration of advanced methods of heterogeneity analysis.
(3) Given the observation that capturing a substrate-bound open state is difficult, it can be assumed that the substrate capture in the catalytic cleft is a fast event. Please comment on the possible time frame of unfolding of substrate and catalysis. Can authors comment on any cryo-EM experiments that can deal with such a short time frame? If there is a possibility to include data from such experiments, then it may be considered.
This has been addressed in conjunction with the previous reviewer’s comment (see above). Specifically, we now discuss the open/closed transition (~0.1 second) and insulin cleavage (~2/sec), both established experimentally in prior studies. Additionally, we investigated IDE–insulin interactions by rapidly mixing IDE with a large molar excess of insulin for approximately 120 milliseconds for the cryo-EM single particle analysis. Under these conditions, we observed that both IDE subunits in the dimer predominantly adopt open states, which are distinct from those previously reported. This observation suggests a potential mechanism of allostery in IDE function.
(4) How long was incubation time after adding any substrates, such as insulin? Can different incubation times be tested to generate additional information regarding other conformational states that lie in between open and closed states?
The incubation time for IDE with insulin prior to cryo-EM grid freezing was approximately 30 minutes. We agree that it would be exciting to explore shorter time frames to identify new conformational states. As discussed above, we have rapidly mixed IDE with a large molar excess of insulin for approximately 120 milliseconds for the cryo-EM single particle analysis. Under these conditions, we observed that both IDE subunits in the dimer predominantly adopt open states, which are distinct from those previously reported. This observation suggests a potential mechanism of allostery in IDE function.
(5) A complex network of hydrogen bonding interaction initiated by R668 latching onto N-domain is mentioned in MD simulation studies but it is not clear why cryo-EM experiments did not capture such stabilized structures.
We believe that two main factors have prevented us from observing the hydrogen bonding network in our cryo-EM structures. The first factor is the requirement to freeze the sample in liquid ethane. According to the second law of thermodynamics, lowering the temperature reduces the effect of entropy. Our findings suggest that residue R668 interacts with several neighboring residues through a network of polar and electrostatic interactions, rather than being limited to a single partner. These interactions facilitate both the open-closed transitions and rotational movements between IDE-N and IDE-C. From a thermodynamic perspective, these interactions have both enthalpic and entropic components, and cooling the sample diminishes the entropic contribution. In line with this, we observe that the closed-state domains in our cryo-EM studies are positioned closer together than in our MD simulations, though not as tightly as in crystal structures of IDE. This implies that cryogenic data collection may constrain the interface between IDE-N and IDE-C, which can further alter the equilibrium for the network of R668 mediated interactions.
Secondly, our cryo-EM structures represent ensemble averages of tens to hundreds of thousands of particles. MD simulations indicate that IDE-N and IDE-C can rotate relative to one another, resulting in considerable variability in residue interactions. However, the level of particle density in our cryo-EM data does not permit sufficiently fine classification to resolve these differences. As a result, distinct hydrogen bonding networks are likely averaged out in the ensemble structure, particularly in the case of R668, which is indicated to interact with multiple neighboring residues in the conformation-dependent manner. This averaging effect may also contribute to our inability to achieve resolutions below 3 Å.
(6) Despite the observation that IDE is an intrinsically flexible protein, it seems probable that differently-sized substrates might reveal additional interaction networks formed by other novel key players apart from just R668. Will it be helpful to first try this computationally using MD simulations and then try to replicate this in cryo-EM experiments? If needed, additional simulation time may be added to the MD analysis. Please comment!
We agree that this is an exciting avenue to explore. Doubly so when considered in light of our R668A enzymatic results with amyloid beta. However, several challenges must be overcome before we can explore this direction effectively:
(1) We lack experimental knowledge of the initial interaction event between IDE and substrate. All substrate-bound IDE structures have been obtained after unfolding and positioning for cleavage has occurred. Without a solid foundational model for the initial interaction event between IDE and substrate, the interpretation of subsequent MD simulations is open to question.
(2) We have previously observed minimal effect of substrate on IDE in all-atom MD simulations. We believe that observable effects would require a much longer time scale than is currently achievable with all-atom MD, so have turned to Upside, a coarse-grained method to overcome these limitations, but Upside handles side chains with presumptive modeling, which prevent the identification of potential novel residue interactions.
(3) Due to the conformational heterogeneity present within IDE cryo-EM datasets, we struggle to obtain sufficient resolution to clearly identify side chain interactions at the domain interface (see response to 5).
Given these challenges, we plan to explore these directions in future manuscripts.
(7) What is the possibility of water interaction networks and dynamism in this network to contribute to the overall dynamics of the protein in the presence and absence of substrates? How symmetric these networks be in the four domains of dimeric IDE?
This is an interesting idea that we have begun to explore, but consider to be outside the scope of this work. Currently, we do not have any MD simulations containing substrate with explicit solvent (Upside uses implicit solvent), and solvent atoms were removed from our all-atom simulations prior to analysis to speed up processing. That being said, preliminary WAXS data suggests that there may be a difference in water interaction interfaces between WT and R668A IDE, and this is a lead we plan to pursue in future work.
(8) Line 214: Please fix the typo which wrongly describes closed = pO.
This is not a typo, but it is confusing. The pO state has previously been defined as the closed state of IDE lacking bound substrate as determined by cryo-EM. This differentiates the pO state from the pC state, where the pC state contains density indicative of bound substrate. As the MD simulations were conducted with the apo-state, the closed state the simulations were initialized from was the pO state structure, which represents the substrate-free closed state as determined by cryo-EM. We realize that this difference is probably unnecessary to the majority of readers, and have removed the (pO) specificity to avoid confusion.
(9) It is not clear why a cryo-EM structure was not attempted for the R668A mutant. If the authors have tried to generate such a structure, it should be mentioned in the manuscript. Such a structure should yield more information when compared to SAXS experiments.
We have not attempted to obtain a cryo-EM structure for the R668A mutant. Our SAXS analysis suggests a transition from a dominant O/pO state to a dominant O/O state. The O/O state is known to exhibit the highest degree of conformational heterogeneity, which severely limits structural insights. We are working to better handle the sample preparation of IDE and perform such analysis without the need to use Fab. We plan to further characterize IDE R668A biochemically and potentially explore other mutations that would provide insights in how IDE works. Armed with that, we will perform the structural analysis of such IDE mutant(s).
-
-
eLife Assessment
The manuscript by Mancl et al. provides valuable mechanistic insights into the conformational dynamics of Insulin Degrading Enzyme (IDE), a zinc metalloprotease involved in the clearance of various bioactive peptides. Supported by a convincing combination of cryo-EM, SEC-SAXS, enzymatic assays, and molecular dynamics simulations, the study characterizes the dynamic transitions between IDE's open and closed states in the presence of a sub-saturating concentration of insulin. This work contributes to a refined model of IDE's functional cycle, enhancing our understanding of its role in proteolysis.
-
Reviewer #1 (Public review):
Summary:
Mancl et al. present cryo-EM structures of the Insulin Degrading Enzyme (IDE) dimer and characterize its conformational dynamics by integrating structures with SEC-SAXS, enzymatic activity assays, and all-atom molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. They present five cryo-EM structures of the IDE dimer at 3.0-4.1 Å resolution, obtained with one of its substrates, insulin, added to IDE in a 1:2 ratio. The study identified R668 as a key residue mediating the open-close transition of IDE, a finding supported by simulations and experimental data. The work offers a refined model for how IDE recognizes and degrades amyloid peptides, incorporating the roles of IDE-N rotation and charge-swapping events at the IDE-N/C interface.
Strengths:
The study by Mancl et al. uses a combination of experimental (cryoEM, …
Reviewer #1 (Public review):
Summary:
Mancl et al. present cryo-EM structures of the Insulin Degrading Enzyme (IDE) dimer and characterize its conformational dynamics by integrating structures with SEC-SAXS, enzymatic activity assays, and all-atom molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. They present five cryo-EM structures of the IDE dimer at 3.0-4.1 Å resolution, obtained with one of its substrates, insulin, added to IDE in a 1:2 ratio. The study identified R668 as a key residue mediating the open-close transition of IDE, a finding supported by simulations and experimental data. The work offers a refined model for how IDE recognizes and degrades amyloid peptides, incorporating the roles of IDE-N rotation and charge-swapping events at the IDE-N/C interface.
Strengths:
The study by Mancl et al. uses a combination of experimental (cryoEM, SEC-SAXS, enzymatic assays) and computational (MD simulations, multibody analysis, 3DVA) techniques to provide a comprehensive characterization of IDE dynamics. The identification of R668 as a key residue mediating the open-to-close transition of IDE is a novel finding, supported by both simulations and experimental data presented in the manuscript. The work offers a refined model for how IDE recognizes and degrades amyloid peptides, incorporating the roles of IDE-N rotation and charge-swapping events at the IDE-N/C interface. The study identifies the structural basis and key residues for IDE dynamics that were not revealed by static structures.
Weaknesses:
Based on MD simulations and enzymatic assays of IDE, the authors claim that the R668A mutation in IDE affects the conformational dynamics governing the open-closed transition, which leads to altered substrate binding and catalysis. The functional importance of R668 would be substantiated by enzymatic assays that included some of the other known substrates of IDE than insulin such as amylin and glucagon.
It is unclear to what extent the force field (FF) employed in the MD simulations favors secondary structures and if the lack of any observed structural changes within the IDE domains in the simulations - which is taken to suggest that the domains behave as rigid bodies - stems from bias by the FF.
-
Reviewer #2 (Public review):
Summary:
The manuscript describes various conformational states and structural dynamics of the Insulin degrading enzyme (IDE), a zinc metalloprotease by nature. Both open and closed-state structures of IDE have been previously solved using crystallography and cryo-EM which reveal a dimeric organization of IDE where each monomer is organized into N and C domains. C-domains form the interacting interface in the dimeric protein while the two N-domains are positioned on the outer sides of the core formed by C-domains. It remains elusive how the open state is converted into the closed state but it is generally accepted that it involves large-scale movement of N-domains relative to the C-domains. The authors here have used various complementary experimental techniques such as cryo-EM, SAXS, size-exclusion …
Reviewer #2 (Public review):
Summary:
The manuscript describes various conformational states and structural dynamics of the Insulin degrading enzyme (IDE), a zinc metalloprotease by nature. Both open and closed-state structures of IDE have been previously solved using crystallography and cryo-EM which reveal a dimeric organization of IDE where each monomer is organized into N and C domains. C-domains form the interacting interface in the dimeric protein while the two N-domains are positioned on the outer sides of the core formed by C-domains. It remains elusive how the open state is converted into the closed state but it is generally accepted that it involves large-scale movement of N-domains relative to the C-domains. The authors here have used various complementary experimental techniques such as cryo-EM, SAXS, size-exclusion chromatography, and enzymatic assays to characterize the structure and dynamics of IDE protein in the presence of substrate protein insulin whose density is captured in all the structures solved. The experimental structural data from cryo-EM suffered from a high degree of intrinsic motion among the different domains and consequently, the resultant structures were moderately resolved at 3-4.1 Å resolution. A total of five structures were generated by cryo-EM. The authors have extensively used Molecular dynamics simulation to fish out important inter-subunit contacts which involve R668, E381, D309, etc residues. In summary, authors have explored the conformational dynamics of IDE protein using experimental approaches which are complemented and analyzed in atomic details by using MD simulation studies. The studies are meticulously conducted and lay the ground for future exploration of the protease structure-function relationship.
-
