Evaluated articles

eLife Assessment

This study presents a valuable open-source and cost-effective method for automating the quantification of male aggression and courtship in Drosophila melanogaster. The work as presented provides solid evidence that the use of the behavioral setup that the authors designed - using readily available laboratory equipment and standardised high-performing classifiers they developed using existing software packages - accurately and reliably characterises social behavior in Drosophila. The work will be of interest to Drosophila neurobiologists and particularly to those working on male social behaviors.

eLife Assessment

This important study provides convincing evidence that glucosylceramide synthase (GlcT), a rate-limiting enzyme for glycosphingolipid (GSL) production, plays a role in the differentiation of intestinal cells. Mutations in GlcT compromise Notch signaling in the Drosophila intestinal stem cell lineage, resulting in the formation of enteroendocrine tumors. Further data suggest that a homolog of glucosylceramide synthase also influences Notch signaling in the mammalian intestine. While the outstanding strengths of the initial genetic and downstream pathway analyses are noted, there are minor weaknesses in the data regarding the potential role of this pathway in Delta trafficking. Nevertheless, this study opens the way for future mechanistic studies addressing how specific lipids modulate Notch signalling activity.

eLife Assessment

TrASPr is an important contribution that leverages transformer models focused on regulatory regions to enhance predictions of tissue-specific splicing events. The revisions strengthen the manuscript by clarifying methodology and expanding analyses across exon and intron sizes, and the evidence supporting TrASPr's predictive performance is compelling. This work will be of interest to researchers in computational genomics and RNA biology, offering an improved model for splicing prediction and a promising approach to RNA sequence design.

eLife Assessment

Fleming et al sought to better understand DNAJC7's function in motor neurons as mutations in this gene have been associated with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). Using iPSC-derived motor neurons, interactome, and transcriptomic data, they provide solid evidence that loss-of-function mutations in DNAJC7 disrupt RNA binding proteins and resistance to proteasomal stress. These important findings advance our understanding of DNAJC7 in motor neurons while providing clues to how its loss may be causal for ALS; nonetheless, the experiments were performed with a single iPSC line, while at least 3 are deemed to be required to validate the results. Furthermore, the mechanistic evidence is still incomplete with respect to how DNAJC7 mutations lead to HSF1 impaired activity, and whether it is direct or not.

eLife Assessment

This study presents valuable findings on the regulation of survival and maintenance of brain-resident immune cells called microglia. Using compelling and sophisticated genetic tools, the authors demonstrate a gene dosage-dependent mechanism using which microglia are eliminated. This research on cell competition and survival will be of broad interest to the cell biology community.

eLife assessment

Using intracellular in vitro and in vivo recordings and a deep learning approach, this study shows that mouse dentate gyrus mossy cells (MCs) and CA3 pyramidal cells process information from an important electrophysiological hall mark of hippocampus, sharp wave-ripples (SWRs). The innovative use of deep learning to predict SWR waveforms from MC membrane potentials represents an interesting methodological advance. While the key findings are potentially fundamental, some of the evidence is currently incomplete and should be revised to better support the findings.

eLife Assessment

The authors make an important contribution to comparative functional genomics by developing a semi-automated computational pipeline that integrates classification and marker-based cluster annotation to identify orthologous cell types. Using a single-cell RNA-seq dataset of induced pluripotent stem cells and derived embryonic bodies from four primate species: humans, orangutans, cynomolgus macaques, and rhesus macaques, the authors provide convincing evidence that cell type-specific marker genes are substantially less transferable across species than broadly expressed genes, with transferability declining as phylogenetic distance increases. This study establishes a key framework and reference dataset for comparative single-cell analyses and encourages more rigorous evaluation of marker gene transferability across species.

eLife Assessment

This study provides a valuable contribution to spatial transcriptomics by introducing MerQuaCo, a computational tool for standardizing quality control in image-based spatial transcriptomics datasets. The tool addresses the lack of consensus in the field and provides robust metrics to identify and quantify common imperfections in datasets. The work is supported by an impressive dataset and compelling analyses, and will be of significant interest to researchers focused on data reproducibility and downstream analysis reliability in spatial transcriptomics.

eLife Assessment

This study provides an important method to model the statistical biases of hypermutations during the affinity maturation of antibodies. The authors show convincingly that their model outperforms previous methods with fewer parameters; this is made possible by the use of machine learning to expand the context dependence of the mutation bias. They also show that models learned from nonsynonymous mutations and from out-of-frame sequences are different, prompting new questions about germinal center function. Strengths of the study include an open-access tool for using the model, a careful curation of existing datasets, and a rigorous benchmark; it is also shown that current machine-learning methods are currently limited by the availability of data, which explains the only modest gain in model performance afforded by modern machine learning.

eLife Assessment

Using an unbiased approach, this important study discovered a role of Ezh2 in the differentiation of granule neuron precursors, the cell of origin for Shh group of medulloblastoma. Furthermore, the authors also provided solid evidence that combined inhibition of Ezh2 and CDK4/6 likely represents a promising strategy for the treatment of this subgroup of MB. Validation of these findings using the FDA-approved Ezh2 inhibitor is needed to further strengthen this preclinical study.

eLife Assessment

This study presents valuable findings suggesting that the late maturation of prefrontal cortex-based control processes enhances conceptual learning by allowing a period of less-constrained knowledge acquisition. The authors provide convincing computational evidence that delayed semantic control promotes learning without compromising representation integrity, with the strongest benefits emerging when control connections target intermediate layers of the model. However, the model's narrow scope raises concerns about scalability to more complex, real-world learning environments, and the meta-analysis, while supporting the developmental trajectory, does not directly test the model's specific predictions regarding task outcomes or error patterns.

eLife Assessment

The study presents important findings regarding the incidence and clinical impact of a mutation in a cardiac muscle protein and its association with the development of atrial fibrillation. The authors provide convincing evidence of electrophysiological disturbances in cells with this mutation and of its association with atrial fibrillation, which would be of interest to cardiologists. Evidence supporting the conclusion that this mutation causes atrial fibrillation would benefit from more rigorous electrophysiologic approaches.

eLife Assessment

This important study analyzes the effect of heat treatment on phage-bacterial interactions and convincingly shows that prior heat exposure alters the bacterial cell envelope, enhancing persistence and bacterial survival when exposed to lytic phages. The study will interest researchers working on antibiotic resistance, tolerance, and phage therapy.

eLife Assessment

This is an important study that examines the impact of Streptococcus pneumoniae genetics on its in vitro growth kinetics, aiming to identify potential targets for vaccines and therapeutics. The study identified significant variations in growth characteristics among capsular serotypes and lineages, linked to phylogeny and high heritability, but genome-wide association studies did not reveal specific genomic loci associated with growth features independent of the genetic background. The evidence supporting these findings is convincing.

eLife Assessment

This study establishes a methodology (machine vision and gaze pose estimation) and behavioral apparatus for examining social interactions between pairs of marmoset monkeys. It has been difficult to study social interactions using artificial stimuli rather than genuine interactions between unrestrained animals. This study makes a fundamental contribution to social neuroscience research in a laboratory setting. Their results are convincing showing that the study of unrestrained social interactions is possible with detailed quantification of position and gaze. The methodology presented here is relevant to research in social neuroscience, neuroethology, and primatology.

eLife Assessment

This important study examines the relationship between cognition and mental health and investigates how brain, genetics, and environmental measures mediate that relationship. The methods and results are compelling and well-executed. Overall, this study will be of interest in the field of population neuroscience and in studies of mental health.

eLife Assessment

This important study examined orientation representations along the visual hierarchy during perception and working memory. The authors provide results suggesting that during working memory there is a gradient where representations are more categorical in nature later in the visual hierarchy. The evidence presented is solid, most notably a match between behavioral data, though minor weakness can be attributed to the tasks and behaviors not being designed to address this question. The findings should be of interest to a relatively broad audience, namely those interested in the relationship between sensory coding and memory.

eLife Assessment

The songbird vocal motor nucleus HVC contains cells that project to the basal ganglia, the auditory system, or to downstream vocal motor structures. In this fundamental study, the authors conduct optogenetic circuit mapping to clarify how four distinct inputs to HVC act on these distinct HVC cell types. They provide compelling evidence that all long range projections engage inhibitory circuits in HVC and can also exhibit cell-type specific preferences in monosynaptic input strength. Understanding HVC at this microcircuit level is critical for constraining models of song learning and production.