Evaluated articles

eLife Assessment

This fundamental study reveals that aging in yeast leads to chromosome mis-segregation due to asymmetric partitioning of chromosomes, driven by disruption of the nuclear pore complex and pre-mRNA leakage. The findings are convincingly supported by carefully-designed experimental data with a combination of genetic, molecular biology and cell biology approaches.

eLife Assessment

This study provides important insights into the role of polyUbiquitination in neurodegenerative diseases, elucidating how pUb promotes neurodegeneration by affecting proteasomal function. The findings not only offer a new perspective on the pathophysiology of neurodegenerative diseases but also provide potential targets for developing new therapeutic strategies. The results provide solid evidence to support the conclusions.

eLife Assessment

Using highly sophisticated switching linear dynamical systems (SLDS) analyses applied to functional MRI data, this study provides important insights into network dynamics underlying threat processing. After identifying distinct neural network states associated with varying levels of threat proximity, the paper provides compelling evidence of intrinsically and extrinsically driven contributions to these within-state dynamics and between-state transitions. Although the findings could be made more biologically meaningful, this work will be of interest to a wider functional neuroimaging and systems neuroscience community.

eLife Assessment

This important study of regulatory elements and gene expression in the craniofacial region of the fat-tailed dunnart shows that, compared to placental mammals, marsupial craniofacial tissue develops in a precocious manner, with enhancer regulatory elements as primary driver of this difference. The compelling data, including a new dunnart genome assembly, provide an invaluable reference for future mammalian evolution studies, especially once additional developmental time point for the fat-tailed dunnart become available.

eLife Assessment

This fundamental work substantially advances our understanding of episodic memory by proposing a biologically plausible mechanism through which hippocampal barcode activity enables efficient memory binding and flexible recall. The evidence supporting the conclusions is convincing, with rigorously validated computational models and alignment with experimental findings. The work will be of broad interest to neuroscientists and computational modelers studying memory and hippocampal function.

eLife Assessment

This study provides important insights into how a specific brain region controls innate responses to odors, showing that different parts of this region govern behaviors related to attraction and aversion. The findings are convincing and supported by a combination of well-executed experimental approaches, including genetic manipulations and neural activity mapping, though the evidence could be strengthened by addressing certain methodological concerns, such as clarifying the rationale for specific experimental choices and exploring alternative techniques.

eLife Assessment

This important study presents an evaluation of several tools used for detecting Identity-By-Descent (IBD) segments in highly recombining genomes, using simulated data to replicate the high recombination and low marker density of Plasmodium falciparum, the parasite responsible for malaria. The evidence presented by the authors is convincing demonstrating that users should be cautious calling IBD when SNP density is low and recombination rate is high. This study will be of interest to scientists working in the field of genome evolution and infectious diseases

eLife Assessment

This valuable observational study was conducted in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania, to investigate potential associations between genetic variation in Mycobacterium tuberculosis and human host vs. disease severity. The authors conclude that human genetic ancestry did not contribute to tuberculosis severity and the evidence supporting this is generally convincing. The findings have significance for the understanding of the influence of host/bacillary genetics on tuberculosis disease.

eLife Assessment

This study examined how multidimensional social relationships influence social attention in rhesus macaques, linking individual and group-level behaviors to attentional processes. The findings that oxytocin altered social attention and its relationship to both social tendencies and dyadic relationships are important, as recent technological advances allow for the exploration of neuronal activities and mechanisms in free-moving macaques. This work is convincing and will be of interest to those studying the interplay between social dynamics and information processing in primates.

eLife Assessment

This study presents a platform to implement closed-loop experiments in mice based on auditory feedback. The authors provide solid evidence that their platform enables a variety of closed-loop experiments using neural or movement signals, indicating that it will be a valuable resource to the neuroscience community. However, the demonstration experiments could be strengthened by increasing the sample size for several groups in the neurofeedback experiments, as well as a more thorough description of the results in the text.

eLife Assessment

This important study conducted experiments to quantify how neural activity independent changes in fluorescence might affect two-photon recordings when using diverse sensors. The researchers found a widespread presence of neural-activity-independent artifacts in two-photon imaging and provide convincing evidence that these artifacts are most likely caused by hemodynamic occlusion. Their findings underscore the importance of accounting for these artifacts when interpreting functional two-photon recordings.

eLife Assessment

This valuable study uses a novel method to record spine calcium responses without the confounds of backpropagating action potentials to study how the dendritic integration of large numbers of inputs generates the tuned output of cortical neurons. While the results are generally solid, the study would benefit from more details, characterizations, and quantifications, including better validation of the method to suppress backpropagating action potentials.

eLife Assessment

This study is important, and the findings add substantially to the evidence base regarding CCR5 antagonist drugs for neuroprotection and stroke management. The authors adhered to the expected systematic review and meta-analysis standards, and the presented evidence is convincing.

eLife Assessment

This important study introduces a fully differentiable variant of the Gillespie algorithm as an approximate stochastic simulation scheme for complex chemical reaction networks, allowing kinetic parameters to be inferred from empirical measurements of network outputs using gradient descent. The concept and algorithm design are convincing and innovative. While the proofs of concept are promising, some questions are left open about implications for more complex systems that cannot be addressed by existing methods. This work has the potential to be of significant interest to a broad audience of quantitative and synthetic biologists.

eLife Assessment

In this important manuscript, Ryan et al perform a genome-wide CRISPR based screen to identify genes that modulate TDP-43 levels in neurons. They identify a number of genes and pathways and highlight the BORC complex, which is required for anterograde lysosome transport as one such regulator of TDP-43 protein levels. Overall, this is a convincing study, which opens the door for additional future investigations on the regulation of TDP-43.

eLife Assessment

This study presents a valuable finding on a new role of glia in activity-dependent synaptic remodeling using the Drosophila NMJ as a model system. The evidence supporting the claims of the authors is convincing. The authors have addressed most of the reviewers' concerns and help to further clarify the claims. The work will be of interest to neuroscientists working on glia-neuron interaction and synaptic remodeling.

eLife Assessment

This manuscript describes an important finding of the transcriptional control of a chimeric gene transfer agents (GTA) cluster in Bartonella by a processive anti-termination factor (BrrG). The evidence provided is convincing. This manuscript will interest researchers working on transcriptional regulation, horizontal gene transfer, and phages.

eLife Assessment

This is a valuable study and a promising development for the field of open-source microscopy for educational purposes. The strengths include the low cost of constructing the microscope, impressive performance and detailed resources including a dedicated website and YouTube channel. The claims are generally supported by solid evidence, however, the manuscript would be strengthened by inclusion of further details on standard performance metrics (e.g. signal to noise ratio etc.) compared to existing systems and further details and clarification on the microscope, construction and operation.

eLife Assessment

This valuable study provides insights into the structure and function of bacterial contractile injection systems that are present in the cytoplasm of many Streptomyces strains. A convincing high-resolution model of the structure of extended forms of the cytoplasmic contractile injection system assembly from Streptomyces coelicolor is presented, with some investigation of the membrane protein CisA in attachment of the extended assembly to the inner face of the cytoplasmic membrane and the firing of the system. The work expands the current understanding of these diverse bacterial nanomachines.

eLife Assessment

In this highly innovative study, Carpenet C et al explore the use of nanobody-based PET imaging to track proliferative cells after in vivo transplantation in mice, in a fully immunocompetent setting. The development of a unique set of PET tracers and mouse strains to track genetically-unmodified transplanted cells in vivo is an important novel asset that could potentially facilitate cell tracking in different research fields. The evidence provided is compelling as the new method proposed might facilitate overcoming certain limitations of alternative approaches, such as full sized immunoglobulins and small molecules.