Evaluated articles

eLife Assessment

This valuable study presents a comparative dataset on crab locomotion to examine the evolution of sideways walking. The evidence supporting the authors' claims is largely convincing. This work will be of interest to researchers in animal locomotion.

eLife Assessment

This study provides valuable insights into the role of MATR3 in oocyte maturation and folliculogenesis, using conditional knockout mice and in vitro follicle culture systems to show that MATR3 is required for oocyte growth and gene transcription, with downstream effects on follicle development. The strength of the evidence is incomplete, as key findings lack independent validation, methodological details are insufficient, and inconsistencies in data presentation reduce confidence in the conclusions. The work will be of interest to researchers in reproductive biology and fertility.

eLife Assessment

This valuable article provides a convincing and very detailed model of the process regulating the assembly of the spore coat in the model spore-forming bacterium Bacillus subtilis. It focuses on SafA, a morphogenetic coat protein involved in the assembly of the spore coat inner layer, deciphering the contributions of disulfide bond formation and crosslinking reactions catalyzed by a transglutaminase. The process had been studied with a combination of genetics and microscopy, but this is the first complete assessment incorporating detailed biochemical approaches.

eLife Assessment

This important paper substantially advances our understanding of how Molidustat may work, beyond its canonical role, by identifying its therapeutic targets in cancer. This study presents a compelling and well-structured investigation into the therapeutic vulnerabilities of APC-mutant colorectal cancer. This work will be of broad interest to the cancer community in studying small molecules and their therapeutic targets.

eLife Assessment

In this important study, the authors demonstrate that generative AI techniques (restricted Boltzmann machine) can be used effectively to design and characterize mutational pathways of WW domains with different binding specificities. The computational studies are complemented by experimental validations, and the results provide solid evidence supporting the idea that sequence landscape holds significance in understanding protein evolution from a transition path perspective. The minor weakness of the study in the current form concerns limited success in designing variants with smoothly varying binding specificities. Nevertheless, the work will likely have a major impact on research aimed at understanding how evolution navigates fitness landscapes as well as reconstructing ancestral sequences.

eLife Assessment

This study represents a useful finding on the social modulation of the complex repertoire of vocalizations made across a variety of strains of lab mice. The evidence supporting the claims is, at present, incomplete, as numerous concerns regarding the appropriate categorization of vocalizations, the averaging of data points with disparate levels of occurrence, the interpretation of the function of noisy calls, and a general lack of adequate analyses of experimental data were raised. With these issues addressed, the work will be of importance to scientists studying rodent vocal communication.

eLife Assessment

This manuscript uncovers the importance of Vinculin in the maintenance of junctional integrity during neural tube closure in regions of increased mechanical stress, by using sophisticated methods such as laser ablation and live imaging. The manuscript also reports a novel application of an established embryonic stem cell protocol to efficiently generate mutant and transgenic embryos for analysis. The findings are fundamental in nature, significantly improve our understanding of a major research question, and are backed by compelling evidence. Whilst there is much to appreciate in this work, exactly how Vinculin mediates neural fold elevation remains unclear, and addressing this lacuna will significantly improve the strength of the manuscript; in addition, some rewriting for better clarity (including technical/methodological details) and inclusion of possible consequences of the increased number of tight junction gaps in the vinculin mutant would be pertinent.

eLife Assessment

In this important study, a new multi-scale imaging workflow promises to accelerate and democratize comparative connectomics, with projectome-level data informing synapse-level connectivity. While the pipeline and time savings are convincing, the evidence for the segmentation methodology as a reusable community resource is incomplete, with key metrics like error rates, annotation times, and proof-reading times not reported. Furthermore, the evidence on the utility of projectome-level information for analysing brains appears misleading. By clarifying the findings and ensuring that the complete software pipeline is available in online open source repositories alongside precise documentation, the authors would deliver on their vision to enable any laboratory to map and analyse brain connectomes.

eLife Assessment

It remains unclear how human antibody-secreting cells (ASCs) differentiate. In this study, the authors discovered a CD30⁺ intermediate subset that appears during the transition from B cells to ASCs, providing a potential ontogeny for extra-germinal center B cell differentiation. This study is useful because it identifies novel intermediate markers that enable tracking of human ASC ontogeny, offering new insights into ASC development. However, the evidence is incomplete, and we see three major limitations: (1) the data are largely representative, requiring additional reproducibility; (2) the bioinformatics analysis is limited; and (3) step-wise phenotypic validation would require lineage-tracing experiments on sorted populations.

eLife Assessment

This multi-omics study provides a comprehensive characterization of the context-dependent roles of the JAK-STAT pathway (JSP) across different cellular compartments within the breast cancer microenvironment. The authors present convincing evidence that high JSP activity paradoxically drives anti-tumor cytotoxicity in T cells but promotes malignancy and immunosuppression in tumor epithelial cells, leading to the fundamental discovery that broad JAK-STAT inhibition could be therapeutically counterproductive. Ultimately, the identification of the immune-related JSP score and the STAT4 axis as predictive biomarkers for anti-PD-1 immunotherapy response, particularly in triple-negative breast cancer, offers critical insights for precise patient stratification and targeted therapeutic interventions.

eLife Assessment

This manuscript demonstrates the feasibility and potential value of using functional MRI in awake, behaving mice, enabling assessment of distributed brain activity during ongoing behavior in a manner analogous to human fMRI. The valuable findings suggest that the periaqueductal gray (PAG), a midbrain structure classically linked to threat processing and aversive learning, also contributes to reversal learning. If supported, this result would carry theoretical and practical implications for our subfield by expanding the computational roles attributed to the PAG and motivating cross-species circuit-level investigations. However, the strength of evidence is, at present, incomplete, and several key claims are only partially supported by the current analyses.

eLife Assessment

Using isolated frog brainstem preparations, pharmacological manipulation of excitability, systematic extracellular unit mapping, and focal microinjections, this study provides important findings on whether the buccal rhythm generator is a discrete anatomical nucleus or a distributed, state-dependent network. The question is conceptually significant and of interest to researchers working within respiratory neurobiology and rhythmogenicity in general, and the preparation and experimental strategy are generally appropriate. However, the evidence for the strongest architectural claims is incomplete, with pseudoreplication in pooled unit-mapping analyses, inconsistent statistical reporting, and limited controls in necessity/sufficiency experiments. Overall, although data are largely convincing, substantial revision and more nuanced interpretation of the results are required before claims of state-dependent architectural reorganization can be considered well-supported.

eLife Assessment

In this important study, Bready et al. investigate how a highly conserved long-range enhancer mediates neural-specific SOX2 regulation during neural differentiation using human neural stem cells. This study has broad appeal to developmental neuroscience; however, the data remain incomplete given the need for homozygous enhancer knockouts and biological replicates in the scRNAseq assays.

eLife Assessment

Mechanical transduction channels of sensory hair cells possess lipid scramblase activity. Membrane lipid disruption resulting from mechanical transduction is thought to be restored by flippase activities. This fundamental study provides compelling evidence that ATP8B1, a P4-ATP flippase and its subunit TMEM30B, are key in mediating this restorative function in outer hair cells of the mammalian cochlea.

eLife Assessment

This important study measures single-unit activity in the middle temporal area (MT) of awake-behaving monkeys to test the idea that sensory adaptation contributes to flexible evidence accumulation during decision-making. Solid evidence is provided, showing that adaptation to different temporal contexts shapes both perceptual judgements and neural responses, but analyses aimed at establishing a direct link between them are less persuasive. This work has the potential to be of interest to a broad range of researchers working on visual perception, plasticity, and decision making.

eLife Assessment

This important study developed a novel paradigm combined with EEG recordings to examine the neural mechanisms underlying temporal integration in perception and its modulation by prior history (i.e., the serial dependence effect). The results provide solid evidence that two key EEG features, namely the individual alpha frequency and the aperiodic slope, jointly and independently shape perceptual integration and its reliance on prior information. While additional control analyses would further strengthen the main conclusions, the findings will be of broad interest to researchers studying perception, decision-making, inter-individual differences, and brain rhythms.

eLife Assessment

Using the clownfish model, this study examines how growth, feeding, and agonistic behavior result in socially dominant or subordinate states in size- and age-matched individuals of the clownfish, Amphiprion percula. The authors complement this work with whole-body transcriptomics and find significant variation in genes and gene co-expression modules related to growth and satiety-related pathways, as well as ossification-related genes. They provide solid evidence that emerging dominants grow more, eat more, and behave more aggressively than subordinate or solitary individuals; these phenotypic differences are accompanied by distinct gene expression profiles, including variation in growth- and satiety-related pathways. The work is valuable in advancing our understanding of how the social environment regulates phenotypic change; however, claims regarding the mechanistic role of gene expression are only partially supported by the current analyses.

eLife Assessment

This valuable study presents a real-time system for identifying multiple unrestrained marmosets in a home cage setting using a combination of face detection and color-coded beads. However, there is incomplete evidence regarding the generalizability and robustness of the system to unconstrained multi-animal environments.

eLife Assessment

This valuable study introduces a new framework for improving the automated sorting of extracellular action potentials. However, the evidence is incomplete; the biophysical model used for simulation is based on one simulation that does not necessarily reflect real experimental data, the test datasets are insufficiently diverse, and essential algorithmic details are currently missing. This work will be of interest to neuroscientists using high-density multichannel electrophysiology.

eLife Assessment

This useful study addresses the interesting question of how immune cells recognise infected erythrocytes in malaria. It proposes the parasite protein PfGBP-130 as an interaction partner of the human cell surface protein LFA 1, which could help explain how NK cells recognize infected erythrocytes. The conclusions are partially supported by pull-down and cell-based activation data. However, the overall evidence of direct interaction at the cell-cell interface and downstream effects is incomplete; stronger evidence is required to demonstrate surface exposure of PfGBP-130, as well as a direct role of this antigen in killing.