Prenatal methadone exposure disrupts behavioral development and alters motor neuron intrinsic properties and local circuitry

Curation statements for this article:
  • Curated by eLife

    eLife logo

    Evaluation Summary:

    This work studied mice that had already taken oxycodone that then were switched to methadone treatment prior to becoming pregnant, to model prenatal methadone exposure (PME). The experimental design featured a study of a wide array of measures in the next generation progeny: including physical development, sensorimotor behavior, vocalizations, brain imaging, electrophysiology, and histology. All three reviewers agreed this work provides a novel, thorough, and highly clinically-relevant model of PME that has high value to the field of neuroscience of addictions and developmental neuropharmacology.

    (This preprint has been reviewed by eLife. We include the public reviews from the reviewers here; the authors also receive private feedback with suggested changes to the manuscript. Reviewer #1 and Reviewer #2 agreed to share their names with the authors.)

This article has been Reviewed by the following groups

Read the full article See related articles

Abstract

Despite the rising prevalence of methadone treatment in pregnant women with opioid use disorder, the effects of methadone on neurobehavioral development remain unclear. We developed a translational mouse model of prenatal methadone exposure (PME) that resembles the typical pattern of opioid use by pregnant women who first use oxycodone then switch to methadone maintenance pharmacotherapy, and subsequently become pregnant while maintained on methadone. We investigated the effects of PME on physical development, sensorimotor behavior, and motor neuron properties using a multidisciplinary approach of physical, biochemical, and behavioral assessments along with brain slice electrophysiology and in vivo magnetic resonance imaging. Methadone accumulated in the placenta and fetal brain, but methadone levels in offspring dropped rapidly at birth which was associated with symptoms and behaviors consistent with neonatal opioid withdrawal. PME produced substantial impairments in offspring physical growth, activity in an open field, and sensorimotor milestone acquisition. Furthermore, these behavioral alterations were associated with reduced neuronal density in the motor cortex and a disruption in motor neuron intrinsic properties and local circuit connectivity. The present study adds to the limited body of work examining PME by providing a comprehensive, translationally relevant characterization of how PME disrupts offspring physical and neurobehavioral development.

Article activity feed

  1. Reviewer #3 (Public Review):

    In this article, Gregory Grecco and colleagues developed a novel translational mouse model of prenatal methadone exposure (PME) that closely resembles the opioid exposure experienced by pregnant women living with opioid use disorder and treated with methadone maintenance pharmacotherapy. The article delineates the impact of prenatal methadone exposure on physical development and motor behavior of the next generation male and female progeny. The authors also relied on a combination of electrophysiological, immunohistochemical and volumetric MRI imaging approaches to investigate the mechanisms underlying PME-derived phenotypes in male and female offspring. Overall, PME produced changes in motor function, motor coordination and growth in progeny. These phenotypes were accompanied by changes in the electrophysiological properties and density of neurons in the primary motor cortex of offspring raised by opioid-exposed dams.

    One of the stated goals by the authors was to develop a mouse model that closely mirrored exposure and dosing regimens in clinical populations living with opioid use disorder in order to increase the translational value of the findings outlined in this report. One of the strengths of the article is the experimental design and the longitudinal nature of the studies. The dams were first treated with oxycodone, a commonly abused pain killer to mimic this condition in patients living with SUD. 5 days prior to mating, the animals were switched to methadone to model maintenance pharmacotherapy that is commonly used in SUD patients. The doses of oxycodone and methadone were carefully selected to mimic as closely as possible the suspected exposure experienced by pregnant women and their unborn offspring. The authors demonstrated that the concentrations of methadone and related metabolites were present in the plasma, brain and placentas of dams and offspring in the opioid-treated group during gestation, parturition and up to one week after birth. Another strength of the study was the fact that the authors convincingly demonstrated a lack of change in maternal behavior in the opioid-treated dams, which could have been a major confounding factor. The dams exposed to oxycodone and methadone did develop dependence to opioids as expected, however the amount and nature of maternal care delivered to their offspring was not affected by oxycodone and methadone exposure. This critical finding enabled the authors to delve further into the biological underpinnings of the observed phenotypes. The offspring produced by opioid-exposed dams showed some phenotypes consistent with neonatal opioid withdrawal syndrome (NOWS) in humans, including hyperthermia and twitches or jerks. Together, these findings demonstrate that the authors were successful in creating a novel model of prenatal opioid use and methadone maintenance in mice.

    Overall, both males and females produced by opioid-treated dams had lower body weight and length during development and through adolescence. Bone volume was also lower in PME offspring compared to controls at 1 week of age, an effect that dissipated by adolescence in PME progeny. Locomotor activity was reduced at P1 and increased at P7 and P21. Interestingly, ultra sonic vocalization emitted by pups when separated from their mothers, was highest for PME females compared to all groups and this increase in calls also coincided with increased activity. PME offspring also had delays in demonstrated coordinated motor behaviors such as acquisition of surface righting, forelimb grasp and cliff aversion during the early stages of development. Prepulse inhibition, a measure of sensorimotor gating was not disrupted by PME.

    At the anatomical level, the largest impact of PME was found in the primary motor region of the cortex, where cell density was reduced particularly in the upper cortical layers. Next, the authors probed the properties of cells and circuits in primary motor cortex and found reduced firing rates in response to injected currents in PME animals compared to controls. The input resistance of these cells was also diminished in the PME group. Together, these findings suggest that the number of cells may be reduced by PME in primary motor cortex and that the remaining neurons are not able to fire as effectively, resulting in blunted transmission within this brain region. Lastly, the authors stimulated local synaptic inputs to M1 using glutamate uncaging and found that the neural circuits connecting the top layers of M1 to layer 5 are enhanced in PME animals.

    Overall, the authors identified some electrophysiological correlates of altered motor function and coordination produced by a novel prenatal opioid exposure model and regimen. This article had several strengths highlighted above but also included some areas of potential improvement. The authors included both sexes in many of their analyses but it is not always clear when the sex of the offspring were combined in the analyses and/or whether sex was always included as a factor in the many endpoints described in the paper. The authors acknowledge some of the limitations of their model in better understanding OUD in pregnant women. Including the caveat that many women do not switch to maintenance therapy prior to conception would be worth mentioning. Moreover the use of buprenorphine has increased in recent years and methadone is not the only maintenance therapy available. Lastly, the electrophysiological recordings do not exactly coincide with some of the overt phenotypes reported: at P21, the PME animals are hyperactive but the time window does not match with the coordination deficits reported. Overall, these minor weaknesses detracted only slightly from the overall impact and value of the reported findings.

  2. Reviewer #2 (Public Review):

    This manuscript establishes a novel rodent model for prenatal methadone exposure and characterizes various aspects of neurodevelopment in the offspring. Given the global opioid crisis and the rampant rise of drug use by pregnant mothers and incidence of neonatal abstinence/opioid withdrawal syndrome, there is a critical need to determine potential outcomes for children born with this condition. In their model, the investigators use mice that are already taking oxycodone and switched to methadone treatment prior to becoming pregnant, which is a major translational advantage compared to other models where opioid dosing does not start until sometime mid-gestation. The experimental design also included a wide variety of measurable endpoints, including physical development, sensorimotor behavioral tasks, vocalizations, brain imaging, circuit electrophysiology, and histology; this comprehensive approach allows for synthesis of the results that has traditionally been difficult to find in this field, given the vast differences in species, dosing paradigms, etc. Sex differences were also considered, which is especially important given what is known about varying rates of NOWS between males and females. The text is very well-written, including detailed descriptions of statistical analysis.

    Despite overall enthusiasm for the study and its findings, there are some concerns regarding the brain volume analyses as well as potential stress confounds with the experimental design. The analysis of structural differences measured by volumetric MRI showed that there were no appreciable differences across grey matter structures with PME (Supp. Fig. 9). This was surprising, given that regional decreases in brain volume are a consistent finding with prenatal drug-exposed offspring (Yuan et al., 2014 [DOI 10.1038/jp.2014.111]; Sirnes et al., 2017 [DOI 10.1016/j.earlhumdev.2017.01.009]; Nygaard et al., 2018 [DOI 10.1016/j.ntt.2018.04.004]). Traditionally, these deficits tend to be more true for white matter than grey, though the authors do not indicate whether this was investigated.

    The opioid dosing protocol required twice-daily subcutaneous injections for at least 3 weeks (possibly longer, but it was difficult to determine from the text when exactly the treatments were halted). The effects of maternal/prenatal stress, even in the vehicles, cannot be discounted. The authors rightly noted this caveat in the Discussion, but it remains a critical concern in this otherwise well-designed study.

  3. Reviewer #1 (Public Review):

    The authors have succeeded in their attempt to develop and characterize a rigorous preclinical model of prenatal methadone exposure secondary to pre-pregnancy prescription opioid use. The model is a technical advance in terms of the opioid exposure being consistent throughout pregnancy and the outcome measures of methadone impact are rigorous. Many aspects neurodevelopment and key physiological processes are assessed and key knowledge is provided about the effects of prenatal methadone exposure on physical development, sensorimotor behavior and neuronal properties.

    Major strengths include the thoroughness and rigor of analyses and the multiple body systems study. In addition, scientific questions are approached using physical, biochemical and behavioral assessments to fully characterize the effects of prenatal methadone exposure.

    The strengths of this paper outweighs the weaknesses. Weakness are minor and include an incomplete assessment or discussion of whether withdrawal in the postnatal period may explain the pathophysiology described and changes in circuitry. Similarly, white matter analyses are not included MRI assessments confining the results to gray matter brain regions.

  4. Evaluation Summary:

    This work studied mice that had already taken oxycodone that then were switched to methadone treatment prior to becoming pregnant, to model prenatal methadone exposure (PME). The experimental design featured a study of a wide array of measures in the next generation progeny: including physical development, sensorimotor behavior, vocalizations, brain imaging, electrophysiology, and histology. All three reviewers agreed this work provides a novel, thorough, and highly clinically-relevant model of PME that has high value to the field of neuroscience of addictions and developmental neuropharmacology.

    (This preprint has been reviewed by eLife. We include the public reviews from the reviewers here; the authors also receive private feedback with suggested changes to the manuscript. Reviewer #1 and Reviewer #2 agreed to share their names with the authors.)