Secretion is a second fate for p62 and is coupled to KEAP1/NRF2 signaling

Curation statements for this article:
  • Curated by eLife

    eLife logo

    eLife Assessment

    This valuable study uses endogenous HiBiT tagging to show that the autophagy receptor p62 is released from cells in membrane-bound vesicles at a rate comparable to LC3B, with release increasing when lysosomal degradation is blocked, depending on core autophagy genes and on p62's ability to self-assemble. The evidence is solid, but it rests mostly on single experiments; some results differ between figures, and the vesicles themselves are not characterized. The proposed link between this export and the NRF2 stress response is plausible but correlative, as the tools used to test it are broad.

This article has been Reviewed by the following groups

Read the full article

Abstract

Cells degrade the autophagy receptor p62/sequestosome 1 (SQSTM1) in lysosomes. By knocking the HiBiT peptide into the endogenous SQSTM1 locus, we show that export is a second, quantitatively comparable fate. Specifically, p62 leaves cells continuously inside membrane-enclosed carriers at a rate similar to that of LC3B. Blocking lysosomal degradation amplifies release through an ATG5- and FIP200-dependent route, whereas a basal route persists in autophagy-deficient cells. Thus, p62 exits by at least two parallel pathways. Export requires PB1-mediated self-oligomerization but not LC3 binding, Kelch-like ECH-associated protein 1 (KEAP1) binding, or an intact ubiquitin-associated domain. Hence, oligomerization is the sorting determinant. KEAP1 is also released, and dominant-negative RAB27A retains both proteins inside cells and lowers nuclear factor erythroid 2-related factor 2 transcriptional output. Secretion is therefore a second outlet for the p62–KEAP1 module, and its interruption co-varies with a dampened oxidative stress response.

Article activity feed

  1. eLife Assessment

    This valuable study uses endogenous HiBiT tagging to show that the autophagy receptor p62 is released from cells in membrane-bound vesicles at a rate comparable to LC3B, with release increasing when lysosomal degradation is blocked, depending on core autophagy genes and on p62's ability to self-assemble. The evidence is solid, but it rests mostly on single experiments; some results differ between figures, and the vesicles themselves are not characterized. The proposed link between this export and the NRF2 stress response is plausible but correlative, as the tools used to test it are broad.

  2. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

    Summary:

    The authors further develop in this article an approach to quantify the release of EV cargo by fusing the HiBiT fragment of nanoluciferase to the cytosolic end of various proteins, via knock-in (rather than overexpression) in HEK293 cells. They have previously published this approach for several EV-associated proteins (Maeda 2024: tetraspanins, flotillin1, syndecan), or the autophagosome-associated protein LC3, or the mitochondrial protein Tom20 (Saito 2026). They now expand it to p62, another protein involved in the autophagy pathway. Their results convincingly show that p62 is indeed released extracellularly, at low levels spontaneously and mainly associated with larger/denser EVs (10k pellet), and much more after blocking lysosomal activity by BafA1 and mainly in small EVs (100K pellet), as well as in a free form.

    Strengths:

    The authors produce a lot of interesting experiments using knock-in or expression under the control of a mutated CMV promoter to avoid high overexpression of the studied proteins. They nicely decipher the molecular machinery involved in this secretion.

    Weaknesses:

    I am a bit unsatisfied with the way all experiments are presented, as bar graphs show individual dots of technical replicates, rather than individual dots of independent experiments (the authors specify that each experiment was performed at least twice). This representation minimizes the potential inter-experiment variability: for instance, when comparing Figure 3B where relative secretion (in BafA1) is around 25 for 10K vs 140 for 100K, and fig 4A where it is 50 for 10K vs 30 for 100K, there is a 5 fold difference of the rate of secretion in 100K, and the ratio 10K/100K is inversed between the experiments of Figure 3 and Figure 4. It would therefore be highly recommended to show all the figures of secretion rate with individual symbols for each individual experiment (calculating the mean of technical replicates for each experiment).

    It is also unclear if the truncated CMV promoters that induce a not-too-high overexpression of the p62 mutants in Figure 5 are also used for Figure 6 (KEAP and mutants) and in Figure 7 (Rab27 and mutants). If not, can the authors justify that, for these molecules, high overexpression does not preclude interpretation of the results?

    An important technical detail is missing in the WB of Figure 4B, where the authors quantify p62-HiBiT in extracellular vesicle pellets: quantification is done in pellets as compared to the cell lysate, but I did not find how the gels were loaded: equal amounts of protein from cells and pellets, or pellets coming from the same number of producing cells loaded in the gel, or other? Also, this experiment seems to have been performed and quantified only once.

  3. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

    Summary

    In this work by Saito et al., the fate of p62 is studied. Under normal cellular conditions, p62 acts as a cargo receptor, binds cargo, and is recruited to the growing autophagosomal membrane via its interaction with LC3. When lysosomal function is inhibited, these structures can also be secreted in a process called secretory autophagy. This valuable paper tries to address the fate of p62. By fusing a HiBiT peptide at the C-terminus of endogenously expressed p62, extremely low amounts of p62 can be detected in the media surrounding HEK293 cells. Most of the secreted p62 was found in membrane-enclosed structures that are continuously secreted from the cells, a process that is dramatically increased after lysosomal inhibition via BafA1. This process is ATG5- and FIP200-dependent. Interestingly, this process depends on p62's ability to oligomerize, but does not depend on its ability to bind LC3, KEAP1, or poly-ubiquitin. KEAP1 was also detected in these membrane-enclosed vesicles, and its secretion did not depend on p62 interaction, but was also increased upon lysosomal inhibition. The exact secretion mechanism was not fully elucidated in this manuscript, but it was found to be RAB27-dependent. Future studies will be needed to fully map the cellular mechanism behind p62 secretion.

    Strengths

    (1) Fusion of the HiBiT peptide to p62 allows for careful quantification of secreted p62 and is of interest to the wider research community as it is an interesting strategy.

    (2) Work on endogenous expression levels of p62 avoids artifacts due to overexpression and adds to the conclusions of the paper.

    (3) Several mutants were analyzed to assess which binding partners of p62 are co-sorted to secreted vesicles.

    Weaknesses

    (1) The exact form of p62 is not clear. The fractions analyzed are pellets that sedimented at two different centrifugation speeds, supernatant, and whether the signal increases upon detergent addition. No effort was made to do further analyses on what these fractions contain or what they look like.

    (2) As pointed out in the discussion, p62 needs to oligomerize to be sorted to these vesicles, and this process is not dependent on LC3 binding. No efforts were made to exclude binding to other cargo receptors via mutation or knockdown, i.e., NBR1 D50R.

    (3) The supernatant was not fully analyzed. It is unclear whether "soluble" p62 secretion is also continuous, whether it depends on ATG5/FIP200, is affected by lysosome inhibition and whether is it potentially decreased upon p62 oligomerization.

    (4) Besides p62 and KEAP1, the contents of the vesicles were not analyzed, and it is unclear whether they contain lipidated LC3 or other autophagy proteins.

    (5) Some details of the experiments are slightly inconsistent. For instance, in Figure 3C, close to zero p62 is detected in the pellet fraction in the absence of detergent. In Figure 4, there is some p62 detected under those same conditions. I believe both of those experiments were done under the same conditions, yet yielded slightly different results. This does not detract from the conclusions of the paper, however.

    Conclusion/discussion

    The work presented is interesting and sheds light on an under-studied cellular function. The method used in this manuscript is very interesting and has the potential to be widely applicable to answer other research questions in other low-protein concentration scenarios. It will be very interesting to see which other autophagy proteins get secreted and what cellular mechanism is used to achieve this.

  4. Author response:

    We thank the editors and both reviewers for their careful reading of our manuscript and for their constructive and generous assessments. We are pleased that the reviewers found our knock-in HiBiT approach informative and the conclusions well supported. Below we provide provisional clarifications on several technical points and outline the revisions we plan to include in the revised version. A full point-by-point response will accompany the revised manuscript.

    Reviewer #1 (Public review):

    (1) Presentation of bar graphs: technical replicates versus independent experiments; apparent discrepancy between Figure 3B and Figure 4A.

    We apologise for the lack of clarity in our description of replication, and we are grateful for the opportunity to correct it here. Our statement that each experiment was performed “at least twice” was intended to mean that each experiment consisting of three independent biological replicates was itself repeated at least twice — that is, a minimum of six independent experiments in total. In the revised version we will state the experimental design explicitly and will re-plot the secretion data so that each symbol represents one independent experiment (the mean of its technical replicates), with the number of symbols corresponding to the number of independent experiments actually performed.

    Regarding the difference between Figure 3B and Figure 4A, we believe this reflects a difference in culture scale rather than inter-experimental variability per se. Figure 3 was performed in 10-cm dishes (3 × 106 cells in 10 mL of medium, and cultivate for 48 hours), whereas Figure 4 was performed in 1 well of a 12-well plate (5 × 105 cells in 1 mL of medium, and cultivate for 12 hours). The cell density and the cell-number-to-medium-volume ratio therefore differ substantially between the two sets of experiments, and we consider this the most likely explanation for the different relative distribution between the 10K and 100K fractions. We will describe this point carefully in the text and in the figure legends of the revised version so that readers can interpret the two figures appropriately.

    (2) Whether the attenuated CMV promoters used in Figure 5 were also used in Figures 6 and 7.

    This is a fair point, and we will address it experimentally. We plan to introduce the promoter-attenuation system into the KEAP1 expression constructs — generating approximately Δ3, Δ4 and Δ5 variants — and to measure the secretion rate of KEAP1 at these reduced expression levels. If the secretion rate is comparable to that obtained with the wild-type promoter, we will retain the existing data and state explicitly that expression level does not affect the interpretation. If instead the secretion rate changes with expression level, we will generate the corresponding mutants in the attenuated-promoter background and repeat the analysis. We will report the outcome either way in the revised version.

    (3) Missing technical detail on gel loading in Figure 4B, and the number of times this experiment was performed.

    We apologise for this omission. Loading was normalised as a percentage of total, so that the cell lysate and the pellet fractions derived from the supernatant are directly comparable; the band intensities shown can therefore be compared between fractions. We will add a full description of this normalisation to the Materials and Methods of the revised version.

    Regarding replication, this experiment uses the large-scale culture format and is accordingly not one that we repeat many times. We have, however, confirmed reproducibility, and we will state clearly in the revised version how many times the experiment was performed and that the result was reproducible.

    Reviewer #2 (Public review):

    (1) The exact form of secreted p62 was not further characterised.

    We agree that this is an interesting and important question. The amount of secreted p62 is extremely small, however, and further biochemical characterisation is beyond what we can achieve reliably at present. We intend to pursue this in follow-up work, including mass-spectrometric identification of co-secreted proteins, nanoparticle tracking analysis to compare particle size and distribution between fractions, and ion-exchange chromatography to probe the surface charge of the particles. We will report these analyses in a separate study, and we will state the limitation explicitly in the revised discussion.

    (2) Binding to other cargo receptors (e.g. NBR1 D50R) was not excluded.

    We appreciate this suggestion. p62 bodies contain a large number of molecules in a complex, highly interconnected assembly, and the factors within p62 bodies that influence p62 secretion are unlikely to be limited to a single protein; identifying all of them is not straightforward. We therefore consider this an important direction for careful future analysis rather than one we can resolve within the present manuscript, and we will say so in the revised discussion.

    (3) The supernatant fraction was not fully analysed.

    We agree that this point is important, and we plan to address it experimentally in the revised version. We will extend the analysis to all fractions, measuring the 100K supernatant, 100K pellet and 10K pellet for Δ5.0 p62-WT and p62-K7A/D69A in wild-type HEK293T cells and in ATG5 KO and FIP200 KO cells. We expect this to clarify how p62 oligomerisation affects the autophagosome-formation-dependent component of secretion, and in particular whether “soluble” p62 release is continuous, ATG5/FIP200-dependent, and sensitive to lysosomal inhibition.

    (4) Vesicle contents beyond p62 and KEAP1, including lipidated LC3 and other autophagy proteins.

    We have addressed this question in our previous work (Saito et al., FEBS Open Bio, 2026), in which we used LC3 HiBiT knock-in cells for a detailed analysis and also confirmed the secretion of NDP52 and OPTN. We will cite and describe these findings more explicitly in the revised version. As noted above, we recognise proteomic analysis of the secreted fractions as an important task for future work.

    (5) Apparent inconsistency between Figure 3C and Figure 4 in the absence of detergent.

    Reviewer #1 raised a related point, and we believe the same explanation applies: the two experiments differ in culture scale. Figure 3 was performed in 10-cm dishes (3 × 106 cells in 10 mL of medium, and cultivate for 48 hours), whereas Figure 4 was performed in 1 well of 12 well-plate (5 × 105 cells in 1 mL of medium, and cultivate for 12 hours). We will describe this difference carefully in the text of the revised version so that the two figures can be compared on the correct basis. We are grateful to the reviewer for noting that this does not affect the conclusions of the paper.