Modular DNA Barcoding of Nanobodies Enables Multiplexed in situ Protein Imaging and High-throughput Biomolecule Detection
Curation statements for this article:-
Curated by eLife
eLife Assessment
This study presents an important practical modification of the orthogonal hybridization chain reaction (HCR) technique, a promising yet underutilized method with broad potential for future applications across various fields. The authors advance this technique by integrating peptide ligation technology and nanobody-based antibody mimetics - cost-effective and scalable alternatives to conventional antibodies - into a DNA-immunoassay framework, which convincingly merges oligonucleotide-based detection with immunoassay methodologies.
This article has been Reviewed by the following groups
Listed in
- Evaluated articles (eLife)
Abstract
Abstract
Immunodetection methods based on antibody-antigen interactions are routinely used in biological and clinical laboratories. DNA-labeled antibodies offer the advantage of simultaneous detection of multiple target molecules via orthogonal DNA barcode sequences. However, current methods for antibody-DNA conjugation typically involve non-site-specific modifications tailored for each specific application, a process that is labor-intensive and often compromises antibody affinity and specificity. To overcome these limitations, here we present a modular, site-specific, and cost-efficient DNA tagging strategy — multiplexed and modular barcoding of antibodies (MaMBA). Utilizing nanobodies as modular adaptors, MaMBA enables direct site-specific labeling of off-the-shelf IgG antibodies with a one-component design. We first applied MaMBA to develop the misHCR method for highly multiplexed in situ protein imaging via orthogonal hybridization chain reaction (HCR). We then introduced a cleavable version of MaMBA, which allows iterative use of the same HCR probes sets, thereby enhancing the multiplexity of misHCR (misHCRn). misHCRn achieves simultaneous labeling of 12 different target molecules within the same mouse brain sections. We further extended the cleavable MaMBA to develop the barcode-linked immunosorbent assay (BLISA) for multiplexed and high-throughput biomolecule detections. By combining BLISA with next-generation sequencing, we successfully measured SARS-CoV-2 IgG and HBV-associated antigens in a large number of human serum samples. Additionally, we demonstrated a small-scale drug screen by using BLISA to simultaneously detect eight protein targets. In conclusion, MaMBA offers a highly modular and easily adaptable approach for antibody DNA-barcoding, which can be broadly applied in basic research and clinical diagnostics.
Article activity feed
-
-
-
eLife Assessment
This study presents an important practical modification of the orthogonal hybridization chain reaction (HCR) technique, a promising yet underutilized method with broad potential for future applications across various fields. The authors advance this technique by integrating peptide ligation technology and nanobody-based antibody mimetics - cost-effective and scalable alternatives to conventional antibodies - into a DNA-immunoassay framework, which convincingly merges oligonucleotide-based detection with immunoassay methodologies.
-
Reviewer #1 (Public review):
Summary:
This manuscript presents a practical modification of the orthogonal hybridization chain reaction (HCR) technique, a promising yet underutilized method with broad potential for future applications across various fields. The authors advance this technique by integrating peptide ligation technology and nanobody-based antibody mimetics - cost-effective and scalable alternatives to conventional antibodies - into a DNA-immunoassay framework that merges oligonucleotide-based detection with immunoassay methodologies. Notably, they demonstrate that this approach facilitates a modified ELISA platform capable of simultaneously quantifying multiple target protein expression levels within a single protein mixture sample.
Strengths:
The hybridization chain reaction (HCR) technique was initially developed to …
Reviewer #1 (Public review):
Summary:
This manuscript presents a practical modification of the orthogonal hybridization chain reaction (HCR) technique, a promising yet underutilized method with broad potential for future applications across various fields. The authors advance this technique by integrating peptide ligation technology and nanobody-based antibody mimetics - cost-effective and scalable alternatives to conventional antibodies - into a DNA-immunoassay framework that merges oligonucleotide-based detection with immunoassay methodologies. Notably, they demonstrate that this approach facilitates a modified ELISA platform capable of simultaneously quantifying multiple target protein expression levels within a single protein mixture sample.
Strengths:
The hybridization chain reaction (HCR) technique was initially developed to enable the simultaneous detection of multiple mRNA expression levels within the same tissue. This method has since evolved into immuno-HCR, which extends its application to protein detection by utilizing antibodies. A key requirement of immuno-HCR is the coupling of oligonucleotides to antibodies, a process that can be challenging due to the inherent difficulties in expressing and purifying conventional antibodies.
In this study, the authors present an innovative approach that circumvents these limitations by employing nanobody-based antibody mimetics, which recognize antibodies, instead of directly coupling oligonucleotides to conventional antibodies. This strategy facilitates oligonucleotide conjugation - designed to target the initiator hairpin oligonucleotide of HCR -through peptide ligation and click chemistry.
Weaknesses:
The sandwich-format technique presented in this study, which employs a nanobody that recognizes primary IgG antibodies, may have limited scalability compared to existing methods that directly couple oligonucleotides to primary antibodies. This limitation arises because the C-region types of primary antibodies are relatively restricted, meaning that the use of nanobody-based detection may constrain the number of target proteins that can be analyzed simultaneously. In contrast, the conventional approach of directly conjugating oligonucleotides to primary antibodies allows for a broader range of protein targets to be analyzed in parallel.
Additionally, in the context of HCR-based protein detection, the number of proteins that can be analyzed simultaneously is inherently constrained by fluorescence wavelength overlap in microscopy, which limits its multiplexing capability. By comparison, direct coupling of oligonucleotides to primary antibodies can facilitate the simultaneous measurement of a significantly greater number of protein targets than the sandwich-based nanobody approach in the barcode-ELISA/NGS-based technique.
-
Author response:
Reviewer #1 (Public review):
Summary:
This manuscript presents a practical modification of the orthogonal hybridization chain reaction (HCR) technique, a promising yet underutilized method with broad potential for future applications across various fields. The authors advance this technique by integrating peptide ligation technology and nanobody-based antibody mimetics - cost-effective and scalable alternatives to conventional antibodies - into a DNA-immunoassay framework that merges oligonucleotide-based detection with immunoassay methodologies. Notably, they demonstrate that this approach facilitates a modified ELISA platform capable of simultaneously quantifying multiple target protein expression levels within a single protein mixture sample.
Strengths:
The hybridization chain reaction (HCR) technique was …
Author response:
Reviewer #1 (Public review):
Summary:
This manuscript presents a practical modification of the orthogonal hybridization chain reaction (HCR) technique, a promising yet underutilized method with broad potential for future applications across various fields. The authors advance this technique by integrating peptide ligation technology and nanobody-based antibody mimetics - cost-effective and scalable alternatives to conventional antibodies - into a DNA-immunoassay framework that merges oligonucleotide-based detection with immunoassay methodologies. Notably, they demonstrate that this approach facilitates a modified ELISA platform capable of simultaneously quantifying multiple target protein expression levels within a single protein mixture sample.
Strengths:
The hybridization chain reaction (HCR) technique was initially developed to enable the simultaneous detection of multiple mRNA expression levels within the same tissue. This method has since evolved into immuno-HCR, which extends its application to protein detection by utilizing antibodies. A key requirement of immuno-HCR is the coupling of oligonucleotides to antibodies, a process that can be challenging due to the inherent difficulties in expressing and purifying conventional antibodies.
In this study, the authors present an innovative approach that circumvents these limitations by employing nanobody-based antibody mimetics, which recognize antibodies, instead of directly coupling oligonucleotides to conventional antibodies. This strategy facilitates oligonucleotide conjugation - designed to target the initiator hairpin oligonucleotide of HCR -through peptide ligation and click chemistry.
Weaknesses:
The sandwich-format technique presented in this study, which employs a nanobody that recognizes primary IgG antibodies, may have limited scalability compared to existing methods that directly couple oligonucleotides to primary antibodies. This limitation arises because the C-region types of primary antibodies are relatively restricted, meaning that the use of nanobody-based detection may constrain the number of target proteins that can be analyzed simultaneously. In contrast, the conventional approach of directly conjugating oligonucleotides to primary antibodies allows for a broader range of protein targets to be analyzed in parallel.
We would like to clarify that MaMBA was specifically designed to address and overcome the limitations imposed by relying on primary antibodies’ Fc types for multiplexing. MaMBA utilizes DNA oligo-conjugated nanobodies that selectively and monovalently bind to the Fc region of IgG. This key feature allows us to barcode primary IgGs targeting different antigens independently. These barcoded IgGs can then be pooled together after barcoding, effectively minimizing the potential for cross-reactivity or crossover. Therefore, IgGs barcoded using MaMBA are functionally equivalent to those barcoded via conventional direct conjugation approaches with respect to multiplexing capability.
Additionally, in the context of HCR-based protein detection, the number of proteins that can be analyzed simultaneously is inherently constrained by fluorescence wavelength overlap in microscopy, which limits its multiplexing capability. By comparison, direct coupling of oligonucleotides to primary antibodies can facilitate the simultaneous measurement of a significantly greater number of protein targets than the sandwich-based nanobody approach in the barcode-ELISA/NGS-based technique.
As we have responded above, MaMBA barcoding of primary IgGs that target various antigens can be conducted separately. Once barcoded, these IgGs can then be combined into a single pool. Therefore, for BLISA (i.e., the barcode-ELISA/NGS-based technique), IgGs barcoded through MaMBA offer the same multiplexing capability as those barcoded using traditional direct conjugation methods.
In in situ protein imaging, spectral overlap can indeed limit the throughput of multiplexed HCR fluorescent imaging. There are two strategies to address this challenge. As demonstrated in this work with misHCR and misHCRn, removing the HCR amplifiers allows for multiplexed detection using a limited number of fluorescence wavelengths. This is achieved through sequential rounds of HCR amplification and imaging. Alternatively, recent computational approaches offer promising solutions for “one-shot” multiplexed imaging. These include combinatorial multiplexing (PMID: 40133518) and spectral unmixing (PMID: 35513404), which can be applied to misHCR to deconvolute overlapping spectra and increase multiplexing capacity in a single imaging acquisition.
-
-