Improving Antenatal Syphilis Screening and Treatment Coverage in Public Health Facilities in Kampala, Uganda: A Pre-Implementation and Implementation-Phase Study

This article has been Reviewed by the following groups

Read the full article See related articles

Abstract

Introduction

Congenital syphilis (CS) remains a major cause of preventable adverse pregnancy outcomes globally, driven by poor antenatal care (ANC) quality, health-system barriers, and untreated maternal infection. In Uganda, syphilis screening and treatment coverage remains below national targets. We evaluated service-delivery impact of a multi-component syphilis testing and treatment intervention implemented across four public health facilities in Kampala, Uganda.

Methods

Guided by the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research (CFIR), the intervention introduced same-day dual HIV/syphilis antibody testing, on-site treatment, and partner notification at three ANC facilities with women with serological evidence of syphilis or unknown syphilis status and infant follow-up at a tertiary referral hospital. Facility register data were compared between a pre-implementation period (January-December 2020) and the implementation period (June 2021-July 2022) using a modified Poisson regression model adjusting for site.

Results

Syphilis screening among women attending their first ANC visit increased from 55.2% to 88.3% (+33.6%; 95% CI 21.0-46.3; p<0.001); same-day treatment among those testing positive increased from 74% to 100% (difference 26.1; 95% CI 22.4-29.9; p<0.001). Partner testing increased nearly five-fold, from 11.8% to 62% (difference 51.9; 95% CI 46.8-57.0; p<0.001); 23.6% of tested partners were positive. Among the high-risk women, 62% tested positive for syphilis, nearly fifteen-fold higher than the general ANC population, and up to 46% of their infants met criteria for confirmed or possible CS; 41% of whom completed intravenous treatment.

Conclusions

A same-day rapid test-and-treat intervention substantially improved maternal syphilis screening and treatment coverage, even during the COVID-19 pandemic, but partner and infant treatment completion remained major gaps in the care cascade. Structural interventions, including integrated maternal-infant care pathways and targeting of high-risk mothers along with their male partners, are needed to close these gaps and advance progress toward the elimination of mother-to-child transmission of syphilis.

What is already known on this topic

Congenital syphilis (CS) is a major, preventable cause of stillbirth, neonatal death and adverse pregnancy outcomes, driven by missed or late screening, delayed treatment and untreated maternal infection. In Uganda, antenatal syphilis screening and treatment fall below national targets, and it is unclear whether health-system interventions can close these gaps in routine public facilities.

What this study adds

A multi-component intervention (same-day dual HIV/syphilis testing, on-site treatment and partner notification) substantially increased first-visit screening in Kampala public facilities, and all women who tested positive were treated the same day. Partner testing rose several-fold, and many tested partners were positive, revealing a large untreated reservoir. High-risk women had much higher syphilis positivity than the general antenatal population. Nearly half of their infants met criteria for confirmed or possible CS, yet fewer than half of these infants completed intravenous treatment.

How this study might affect research, practice or policy

Same-day test-and-treat is feasible in routine ANC and could be scaled nationally, with targeting of high-risk women and their male partners. Partner and infant treatment completion are the weakest points in the care cascade, so integrated maternal-infant care pathways are needed to advance elimination of mother-to-child transmission. Future research should test strategies to improve partner treatment and infant follow-up and assess the effect on CS incidence and cost-effectiveness.

Article activity feed

  1. This Zenodo record is a permanently preserved version of a PREreview. You can view the complete PREreview at https://prereview.org/reviews/23894351.

    Write a short summary of the research's main findings and how this work has moved the field forward.

    The intervention of this study was introducing same-day HIV/syphilis antibody testing, on-site treatment, and partner notification. The findings of this study include syphilis screening among women attending their first ANC visit going from 55.2% to 88.3%, same-day treatment among those who tested positive increased from 74% to 100%, and partner testing increased from 11.8% to 62%. This work contributes to the field of public health by demonstrating how integrating rapid testing and treatment into routine antenatal care may improve access to timely syphilis services in resource-limited settings.

    Major issues

    • The study lacks a concurrent control group, which means that it may be difficult to determine if the improvements were caused by the intervention or were from other factors.

    • There could be issues with data quality, as the relies on data from January–December 2020 and June 2021–July 2022. Any changes in documentation could influence the observed differences in screening and treatment coverage.

    Minor issues

    • The authors could have discussed the remaining treatment gaps. Although maternal screening and treatment improved substantially, only 41% of eligible infants completed intravenous treatment.

    • The authors could better explain how women were classified as high-risk for syphilis and how infants were classified as having confirmed or possible congenital syphilis.

    Competing interests

    The author declares that they have no competing interests.

    Use of Artificial Intelligence (AI)

    The author declares that they did not use generative AI to come up with new ideas for their review.

  2. This Zenodo record is a permanently preserved version of a PREreview. You can view the complete PREreview at https://prereview.org/reviews/23899226.

    PREreview of Improving Antenatal Syphilis Screening and Treatment Coverage in Public Health Facilities in Kampala, Uganda

    1. Summary

    This study examined whether an intervention could improve syphilis screening and treatment among pregnant women in Uganda. The researchers compared data from before and during the intervention.

    The results showed that syphilis screening increased from 55.2% to 88.3%, and same-day treatment among women who tested positive increased from 74% to 100%. Partner testing also improved, but there were still challenges in providing treatment for infants with confirmed or possible congenital syphilis.

    2. Strengths

    One strength of this study is that the researchers collected data from public health facilities. I think this is important because the results show what happened when the intervention was used in real healthcare settings. The study also included a large number of pregnant women, which makes the findings more useful.

    Another strength is that the researchers did not only focus on pregnant women. They also looked at partner testing and infant treatment. I like this because preventing congenital syphilis is not just about screening pregnant women. Making sure their partners and infants receive care is also important.

    3. Major Comments

    1. Lack of a control group

    My main concern is that the study did not have a control group. Although screening and treatment rates increased, I wonder whether other factors could have affected the results. For example, healthcare services or staffing might have changed during the study period.

    I think it would be helpful if the authors explained whether there were any other changes in the healthcare facilities during this time. Without a control group, it is difficult to know whether the improvements were mainly caused by the intervention.

    2. Same-day treatment and treatment completion

    Another thing I noticed is that receiving treatment on the same day does not always mean that patients completed their treatment.

    I wonder whether the researchers had information about treatment completion. If they did, I think it would be helpful to include this information or explain it more clearly. This is important because receiving treatment and completing treatment are not always the same.

    3. Multiple intervention strategies

    The intervention included several strategies, such as rapid testing, treatment, and partner notification. Since these strategies were introduced together, it is difficult to know which one was the most helpful.

    I think it would be useful if the authors discussed this limitation. It might also be helpful to explain which strategies could be easier for healthcare facilities with limited resources to use.

    4. Do the Results Support the Authors' Conclusions?

    I think the results generally support the authors' conclusions because screening and treatment rates increased during the intervention. However, I think the authors should be careful when saying that the intervention caused these improvements, since other factors might also have contributed.

    I think explaining this limitation more clearly would help readers better understand the findings.

    5. Suggestions for Future Studies

    For future studies, I think it would be helpful to include a control group to better understand the effects of the intervention.

    I also think it would be interesting to explore which intervention strategies were the most helpful, especially for healthcare facilities with limited resources.

    6. Overall Impression

    Overall, I think this is an important study because syphilis during pregnancy can affect both mothers and infants. I also like that the researchers considered different parts of healthcare, including screening, treatment, and follow-up.

    Although the study has some limitations, I think the findings are useful for understanding how

    Competing interests

    The author declares that they have no competing interests.

    Use of Artificial Intelligence (AI)

    The author declares that they used generative AI to come up with new ideas for their review.

    I used AI to translate my thoughts from Mandarin to English, and also used AI to correct my grammar.