Impact of Operator Technique Preference on Thrombectomy Reperfusion Outcomes
Discuss this preprint
Start a discussion What are Sciety discussions?Listed in
This article is not in any list yet, why not save it to one of your lists.Abstract
Background
Randomized trials have shown comparable reperfusion rates among stent-retriever, contact-aspiration, and combined thrombectomy techniques. We aim to evaluate the association between operator device-selection preference and procedural performance metrics.
Methods
Retrospective analysis of prospective data from a comprehensive stroke center. “Preferred technique” was defined as a technique used in >50% of an operator’s thrombectomies. Main exposure: proportion of usage of a given technique by operators in a certain period; primary endpoint: rate of first-pass effect(FPE).
Results
1405 patients fit inclusion criteria. The first time period(2019- mid 2022/n=839) included 4 operators(3 experienced/1 starting practice), with CoT being overall used in 58.9%, SR in 24.4%, and CA in 16.7%. The second(mid 2022-2024/n=566) included 4 total operators(2 experienced/2 starting), with CA reaching 48.2%, CoT 39.8% and SR 12.0%. The distribution of techniques varied between intra-/inter-operators and most(75.0%) had a preferred technique. The technique with the highest FPE rate was never the most used technique. The chances of operators achieving FPE were not dependent on the previous cumulative success for a given technique. Increasing case volume was associated with higher FPE on average, but the learning rate differed by technique and only contact aspiration had a significant learning curve. The parenchymal hemorrhage rates were comparable for individual operators regardless of technique.
Conclusion
Neurointerventionists tended to rely on a preferred technique, which did not necessarily lead to superior reperfusion outcomes. The cumulative success with a given technique did not increase the likelihood of attaining FPE in subsequent cases. Among new operators, a learning curve for contact aspiration was observed.
