Adaptation of an herbivorous arthropod to green tea plants by overcoming catechin defenses
Curation statements for this article:-
Curated by eLife
eLife Assessment
This important study provides mechanistic evidence that tea-adapted two-spotted spider mite overcomes green tea catechin defenses via the horizontally transferred dioxygenase TkDOG15, supporting a two-step adaptation model, combining enzyme refinement and inducible upregulation. The evidence is convincing because multi-omics signals converge with functional validation (RNAi knockdown and recombinant enzyme assays) and well-controlled behavioral/toxicity assays to link TkDOG15 activity and expression to survival and feeding on tea.
This article has been Reviewed by the following groups
Discuss this preprint
Start a discussion What are Sciety discussions?Listed in
- Evaluated articles (eLife)
Abstract
Green tea catechins are known antioxidants that benefit human health and protect tea plants from biotic stressors. However, some herbivores can counteract catechin defenses and can use tea plants as a host. Among herbivorous mites, an extreme generalist Tetranychus urticae has not been reported as a tea pest. Instead, T. kanzawai , another generalist, has some populations that thrive on tea plants. Here, we investigated the mechanism of the adaptation of these mites to tea plants. Comparative study of the intra- and inter-specific variations in mite performances uncovered differences in their behavioral and xenobiotic responsiveness to green tea catechins. We showed that green tea catechins exert complex defensive roles. They were repellent and toxic to T. urticae and tea non-adapted T. kanzawai mites. In addition, they had an antifeedant effect on tea non-adapted T. kanzawai mites. Matching the catechin structure, we identified an intradiol ring-cleavage dioxygenase TkDOG15 , a gene horizontally transferred from fungi, as one required for the adaptation of T. kanzawai mites to tea plants. The TkDOG15 gene has an enhanced inducible expression in tea-adapted T. kanzawai mites. Furthermore, we identified two amino acid substitutions in DOG15 between Tetranychus species leading to the increased efficacy of the T. kanzawai encoded enzyme toward cleavage of green tea catechins. Thus, we showed that mite adaptation to tea plants occurred in a two-step process. The amino acid substitutions in DOG15 predispose T. kanzawai but not T. urticae for the adaptation to tea plants. Further increased expression of modified TkDOG15 enables T. kanzawai mites to efficiently detoxify green tea catechins, leading to intra- and inter-specific differences in mites’ ability to use tea plants as a host.
Article activity feed
-
eLife Assessment
This important study provides mechanistic evidence that tea-adapted two-spotted spider mite overcomes green tea catechin defenses via the horizontally transferred dioxygenase TkDOG15, supporting a two-step adaptation model, combining enzyme refinement and inducible upregulation. The evidence is convincing because multi-omics signals converge with functional validation (RNAi knockdown and recombinant enzyme assays) and well-controlled behavioral/toxicity assays to link TkDOG15 activity and expression to survival and feeding on tea.
-
Reviewer #1 (Public review):
Summary:
This study investigates the molecular mechanisms allowing the KSM mite to infest tea plants, a host that is toxic to the closely related TSSM mite due to high concentrations of phenolic catechins. The authors utilize a comparative approach involving tea-adapted KSM, non-adapted KSM, and TSSM to assess behavioral avoidance and physiological tolerance to catechins. The main finding is that tea-adapted KSM possesses a specific detoxification mechanism mediated by an enzyme, TkDOG15, which was acquired via horizontal gene transfer. The study demonstrates that adaptation is a two-step process: (1) structural refinement of the TkDOG15 enzyme through amino acid substitutions that enhance enzymatic efficiency against catechins, and (2) significant transcriptional upregulation of this gene in response to tea …
Reviewer #1 (Public review):
Summary:
This study investigates the molecular mechanisms allowing the KSM mite to infest tea plants, a host that is toxic to the closely related TSSM mite due to high concentrations of phenolic catechins. The authors utilize a comparative approach involving tea-adapted KSM, non-adapted KSM, and TSSM to assess behavioral avoidance and physiological tolerance to catechins. The main finding is that tea-adapted KSM possesses a specific detoxification mechanism mediated by an enzyme, TkDOG15, which was acquired via horizontal gene transfer. The study demonstrates that adaptation is a two-step process: (1) structural refinement of the TkDOG15 enzyme through amino acid substitutions that enhance enzymatic efficiency against catechins, and (2) significant transcriptional upregulation of this gene in response to tea feeding. This enzymatic adaptation allows the mites to cleave and detoxify tea catechins, enabling survival on a toxic host plant.
Strengths:
A multiomics approach (transcriptomics and proteomics) provided a compelling cross-validation of its findings. Functional bioassays, such as RNAi and recombinant enzyme assays, demonstrated that the adapted mite has higher activity against catechins via TkDOG15. Other methodologies, like feeding assay using a parafilm-covered leaf disc, were effective in avoiding contact chemosensation.
Weaknesses:
Although TkDOG15 is assumed to "detoxify" catechins by ring cleavage, the study doesn't identify or characterize the breakdown metabolic products. If the metabolites are indeed non-toxic compared to the parent catechins, that would strengthen the detoxification hypothesis. Also, the transcriptomic and proteomic analyses identified other potential detoxification enzymes, such as CCEs, UGTs, and ABC (Supplementary Tables 3-1 & 3-2), which were also upregulated. The manuscript focuses almost exclusively on TkDOG15, potentially overlooking a multigenic adaptation mechanism, where these other enzymes might play synergistic roles, although it was mentioned in the discussion section.
-
Reviewer #2 (Public review):
Summary:
The fascinating topic of the host range of arthropods, including insects, and the detoxification of host secondary metabolites has been elucidated through studies of the host specificity of two closely related species. The discovery that key genes were acquired from fungi through horizontal gene transfer (HGT) is particularly significant.
Strengths:
(1) The discovery that the TkDOG15 enzyme, acquired through HGT from fungi, plays a key role in the detoxification of green tea catechins in the Kanzawa mite, revealing a new mechanism of plant-herbivore interactions, is highly encouraging.
(2) The verification of this finding through various experiments, including behavioral, toxicological, transcriptomic, and proteomic analyses, RNAi-based gene function analysis, and recombinant enzyme activity assays, …
Reviewer #2 (Public review):
Summary:
The fascinating topic of the host range of arthropods, including insects, and the detoxification of host secondary metabolites has been elucidated through studies of the host specificity of two closely related species. The discovery that key genes were acquired from fungi through horizontal gene transfer (HGT) is particularly significant.
Strengths:
(1) The discovery that the TkDOG15 enzyme, acquired through HGT from fungi, plays a key role in the detoxification of green tea catechins in the Kanzawa mite, revealing a new mechanism of plant-herbivore interactions, is highly encouraging.
(2) The verification of this finding through various experiments, including behavioral, toxicological, transcriptomic, and proteomic analyses, RNAi-based gene function analysis, and recombinant enzyme activity assays, is also highly commendable.
(3) By proposing a two-step model in which amino acid substitutions and expression regulation of a specific enzyme gene (TkDOG15) enable host adaptive evolution, this study contributes significantly to our understanding of the evolutionary mechanisms of speciation and plant defense overcoming.
Weaknesses:
While transcriptome/proteome analyses reported changes in the expression of other detoxification-related enzymes, including CCEs, UGTs, ABC transporters, DOG1, DOG4, and DOG7, it is regrettable that the contribution of each enzyme, including its interaction with TkDOG15 and the functional analysis of each enzyme within the overall catechin detoxification system, was not investigated.
-
