Cell type-specific immune regulation under symbiosis in a facultatively symbiotic coral
This article has been Reviewed by the following groups
Discuss this preprint
Start a discussion What are Sciety discussions?Listed in
- Evaluated articles (Arcadia Science)
Abstract
Many cnidarians host single-celled algae within gastrodermal cells, yielding a mutually beneficial exchange of nutrients between host and symbiont, and dysbiosis can lead to host mortality. Previous research has uncovered symbiosis tradeoffs, including suppression of immune pathways in hosts, and correlations between symbiotic state and pathogen susceptibility. Here, we used a multiomic approach to characterize symbiotic states of the facultatively symbiotic coral Oculina arbuscula by generating genotype-controlled fragments of symbiotic and aposymbiotic tissue. 16S rRNA gene sequencing showed no difference in bacterial communities between symbiotic states. Whole-organism proteomics revealed differential abundance of proteins related to immunity, confirming immune suppression during symbiosis. Single-cell RNAseq identified diverse cell clusters within seven cell types across symbiotic states. Specifically, the gastrodermal cell clusters containing algal-hosting cells from symbiotic tissue had higher expression of nitrogen cycling and lipid metabolism genes than aposymbiotic gastrodermal cells. Furthermore, differential enrichment of immune system gene pathways and lower expression of genes involved in immune regulation were observed in these gastrodermal cells from symbiotic tissue. However, there were no differences in gene expression in the immune cell cluster between symbiotic states. We conclude that there is evidence for compartmentalization of immune system regulation in specific gastrodermal cells in symbiosis. This compartmentalization may limit symbiosis tradeoffs by dampening immunity in algal-hosting cells while simultaneously maintaining general organismal immunity.
Article activity feed
-
-
host immunity is modulated to facilitate endosymbiosis
It would be useful to show a schematic of the differences in aposymbiotic and symbiotic stony corals, kind of like a graphical abstract. The abstract was hard to follow without reading the details of the study, and it would be nice to see the overall findings in a visual way. This could get across the idea that neither the bacterial communities nor the proportion of immune cells differ between symbiotic states, but the gastrodermis I cells downregulate immune genes when algae is in close contact. That begs the question, will you follow up to determine what chemical cues from the algae are sensed by the gastrodermis cells to alter their gene expression?
-
first 10 Principal Components (PCs)
How many PCs can explain 95% of the variance? And how many features went into the PCA?
-
Immune Cell
I don't think it's necessary to capitalize immune cell while naming the type of cluster.
-
aposymbiotic branches were transferred back to common garden aquaria and maintained for at least 2 months of recovery prior to physiological and multiomic profiling
How do these corals acquire their symbionts? Is it surprising that with 2 months of recovery following the bleaching even that the symbiont load remained so low? Or is there a sensitive window that has closed for corals at this stage of development?
-
