Limitations of current machine learning models in predicting enzymatic functions for uncharacterized proteins
This article has been Reviewed by the following groups
Listed in
- Evaluated articles (Arcadia Science)
Abstract
Thirty to seventy percent of proteins in any given genome have no assigned function and have been labeled as the protein “unknome.” This large knowledge shortfall is one of the final frontiers of biology. Machine learning (ML) approaches are enticing, with early successes demonstrating the ability to propagate functional knowledge from experimentally characterized proteins. An open question is the ability of ML approaches to predict enzymatic functions unseen in the training sets. By integrating literature and a combination of bioinformatic approaches, we evaluated individually Enzyme Commission number predictions for over 450 Escherichia coli unknowns made using state-of-the-art ML approaches. We found that current ML methods not only mostly fail to make novel predictions but also make basic logic errors in their predictions that human annotators avoid by leveraging the available knowledge base. This underscores the need to include assessments of prediction uncertainty in model output and to test for “hallucinations” (logic failures) as a part of model evaluation. Explainable artificial intelligence analysis can be used to identify indicators of prediction errors, potentially identifying the most relevant data to include in the next generation of computational models.
Article activity feed
-
Limitations of current machine learning models in predicting enzymatic functions for uncharacterized proteins https://academic.oup.com/g3journal/article/doi/10.1093/g3journal/jkaf169/8211502
-
Limitations of current machine learning models in predicting enzymatic functions for uncharacterized proteins https://academic.oup.com/g3journal/article/doi/10.1093/g3journal/jkaf169/8211502
-
Limitations of current machine learning models in predicting enzymatic functions for uncharacterized proteins https://academic.oup.com/g3journal/article/doi/10.1093/g3journal/jkaf169/8211502
-
Authors published a paper in Biorxiv, they used InterPro in the study. Including #RRIDs will make this less ambiguous. SciScore made a table with this resource, see “Automated Services” module (download as csv, xml or #jats) #methodsmatter #STMpublishing
-
-
Limitations of Current Machine-Learning Models in Predicting Enzymatic Functions for Uncharacterized Proteins [updated] ML models struggle w/ novel enzymatic function prediction for unknown proteins; lack sci. reasoning.
-
-
A great blog post by @math-rachel.bsky.social on this preprint describing failures of an ML approach for gene annotation: rachel.fast.ai/posts/2025-0... www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1... "how challenging (or even impossible) it can be to evaluate AI claims in work outside our own area of expertise"
-
-
Computational models could help propagate the experimentally validated functional annotations to the correct portion of the protein space
I've wondered whether there might be interesting signatures that could differentiate between 1) inappropriate transfer of functional annotations to seemingly similar proteins vs 2) incomplete annotations, i.e. where the other protein(s) may indeed have the originally hypothesized function AND a second or additional functions on top of this that confuses interpretation. Do you know of any work or models that is attempting to address this?
-
very few of the proteins in UniprotKB54, the most widely used protein function database55, have been linked to experimental data
Curious if you might have a ballpark number in terms of % of entries for which there is direct experimental data? I've been trying to get a sense of this and agree that it's low, but haven't been able to track down a number.
-
Limitations of Current Machine-Learning Models in Predicting Enzymatic Functions for Uncharacterized Proteins www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1... #jcampubs
-
Limitations of Current Machine-Learning Models in Predicting Enzymatic Functions for Uncharacterized Proteins https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.07.01.601547v1
-
Limitations of Current Machine-Learning Models in Predicting Enzymatic Functions for Uncharacterized Proteins https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.07.01.601547v1
-