What do ecology and evolutionary biology journal websites communicate about their policies and preferences regarding replication studies?

This article has been Reviewed by the following groups

Read the full article

Listed in

Log in to save this article

Abstract

The replication of prior research is a cornerstone of the scientific process and valued as such in ecology and evolutionary biology. However, it appears replication studies are nowhere near as prevalent in the published literature as might be expected if they were a routine part of building confidence in research findings. This may be due in part to the widespread perception of replication studies as a low-status activity. Journal policies have an important role in shaping researchers’ behaviour and willingness to conduct and publish replications. Many journals project a preference for novel methods, findings, or ideas, which discourages, and sometimes overtly precludes, submission of replication studies, while others actively invite them. Given this variety, authors have an interest in determining the extent to which replication studies are welcomed by their target journal, but this can be hard to identify from journal websites. We examined what information about journal policy on replication studies could be found on the websites of 233 ecology/evolutionary biology journals. We found that only 31 of 226 eligible journals (13.7%) provided any information about replication studies on their websites. Among journals that provided information on replications, discouraging or not accepting replication studies was more common than actively encouraging them, with only four journals (1.8%) explicitly encouraging replication studies. In addition, 75 (33%) journals used novelty-related language (i.e., language that may implicitly devalue replication work) on their websites. Together, our findings suggest that explicit policies on replication studies remain rare, and that unclear or discouraging signals about replication research are common in ecology and evolutionary biology journals. We therefore provide recommendations to improve the clarity and transparency of journal policies regarding replication studies.

Article activity feed

  1. PCI Ecology has recently endorsed the preprint at https://doi.org/10.32942/X27W95 The recommendation was handled by Tim Parker and is available at https://doi.org/10.24072/pci.ecology.101342

  2. PCI Ecology has recently reviewed the preprint at https://doi.org/10.32942/X27W95 The review was handled by César Marín and is available at https://ecology.peercommunityin.org/articles/rec?id=1342#review-6869

  3. PCI Ecology has recently reviewed the preprint at https://doi.org/10.32942/X27W95 The review was handled by Swastika Issar and is available at https://ecology.peercommunityin.org/articles/rec?id=1342#review-6788

  4. PCI Ecology has recently reviewed the preprint at https://doi.org/10.32942/X27W95 The review was handled by Matheus Salles and is available at https://ecology.peercommunityin.org/articles/rec?id=1342#review-7840

  5. ​​​​​Replicability of results is often considered a defining feature of reliable science. Although many ecologists will endorse this principle when asked, in practice, ecology papers are identified as replications only extremely rarely (Kelly 2019), and, at least in some sub-disciplines (Kelly 2006), papers that could be interpreted as replications rarely present evidence that could be used to assess the validity of a prior claim in the literature (a defining feature of replications, Nosek and Errington 2020). 
     
    The rarity of explicit replication attempts in ecology may result from any number of causes – cultural, biological, or institutional. Cabugos et al. (2026) have chosen to explore a potential role for institutions in influencing the publication of replications through a systematic classification and quantification of policies associated with replication across a large number of ecology and evolutionary biology journals. They found that most ecology and evolution journal websites did not explicitly address the topic of the suitability of replication studies for publication in that journal, and that what information was available often implicitly discouraged replication studies. 
     
    In the face of a paucity of explicit directives related to replication studies, Cabugos et al. (2026) make a series of recommendations to journals for communicating to potential authors on the subject of replication studies. This concise list of recommendations is clear and useful and will hopefully come to the attention of journal editors. If adopted, these recommendations should lead to greater clarity in communication from ecology and evolution journals in the future and hopefully would increase the rate of publication of replication studies in these disciplines. 
     

    References​

    Leyla Cabugos, Joel L. Pick, Marija Purgar (2026) What do ecology and evolutionary biology journal websites communicate about their policies and preferences regarding replication studies?. Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, ver.2 peer-reviewed and recommended by PCI Ecology https://doi.org/10.32942/X27W95
     
    Kelly, C. D. (2006) Replicating empirical research in behavioral ecology: how and why it should be done but rarely ever is. The Quarterly Review of Biology, 81 , 221–236. https://doi.org/10.1086/506236
     
    Kelly, C. D. (2019). Rate and success of study replication in ecology and evolution. PeerJ , 7, e7654. https://doi.org/10.7717/peerj.7654
     
    Nosek BA, Errington TM (2020) What is replication? PLoS Biol 18(3): e3000691. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.3000691
     ​

  6. For EcoEvo journals, is novelty the enemy of the replicable? Interesting preprint by Cabugos et al. suggests most journals discourage replication ecoevorxiv.org/repository/v...