Weapon and Poison: Framing Disinformation in European Commission Speeches, 2016–2024
Discuss this preprint
Start a discussion What are Sciety discussions?Listed in
This article is not in any list yet, why not save it to one of your lists.Abstract
Drawing on 238 speeches delivered by European Commission (EC) presidents, vice-presidents, and commissioners (2016–mid-2024), this paper examines how the ECnarrates “disinformation”. Using topic modelling, text-community detection, andqualitative content analysis, we show a generally self-absolving and fatalisticframing. Disinformation is considered the root cause of unwanted behaviours andevents, naturalized as a technological inevitability given citizen gullibility. Moreover,responsibility for the spread of disinformation is externalized to hostile states, “badactors”, and digital platforms. Battlefield and contagion metaphors (fight/weapon;poison/infodemic) underpin a policy repertoire focused on platform governance,detection/takedown, and media-literacy “vaccines”, positioning citizens as vulnerablesubjects. Temporal analysis traces shifts from Russia-centred attributions to abroadened cast (China, Lukashenko) and, by 2023–24, AI-enabled amplification. Weargue that this framing narrows problem definitions and answers, imposing top-downsolutions instead of supporting democratic dialogue.
