Black Holes as Landauer-Saturating Erasure Channels: Horizon Diagnostics, Area Quantization, and the Measurement Counterpart

Read the full article See related articles

Discuss this preprint

Start a discussion What are Sciety discussions?

Listed in

This article is not in any list yet, why not save it to one of your lists.
Log in to save this article

Abstract

We develop a quantitative framework in which black holes function as erasure channels for exterior classical records at the horizon-side Landauer bound. At asymptotic infinity, greybody scattering turns the full radiation channel into a thermodynamically dissipative filter (in the sense of excess entropy production, not energy loss) whose entropy efficiency \( \eta_\infty \equiv |dS_{BH}|/dS_{\mathrm{rad}} \) is field-content dependent; for the spin-2 (graviton) channel in Schwarzschild evaporation, \( \eta_\infty \approx 0.74 \) (quoted here as the closest-to-saturation channel, not the dominant total-flux channel; Page [1]). Starting from the Cortês-Liddle result that Hawking evaporation saturates the Landauer principle, we make three contributions. First, we define a Landauer saturation ratio \( \mathcal{R}_L \) as a bookkeeping diagnostic for horizon thermodynamics, using exact-first-law black holes as the saturating benchmark and non-unity cases as the main diagnostic payoff: Schwarzschild black holes yield \( \mathcal{R}_L = 1 \) exactly, while the cosmological apparent horizon yields \( \mathcal{R}_L = 1/2 \) in Trivedi’s quasi-local energy accounting. Second, we show that within the standard Bekenstein-Hawking area law and the discrete transition model of Bagchi, Ghosh, and Sen, one-step Landauer-saturating area transitions select the Bekenstein-Mukhanov spacing \( \Delta A = 4\ln 2\, l_P^2 \); this discrete compatibility result complements, rather than derives, the continuous holographic scaling \( S \propto M^2 \). Third, we argue that the black hole scrambling time \( t_* \sim (\hbar/2\pi k_B T_H)\ln (S_{BH}/k_B) \) provides a partial gravitational analogue of the reversibility time \( \tau_c \) in quantum measurement: for an old black hole it sets the delay after which newly injected information can begin to reappear in Hawking radiation. We formalize the horizon as an effective coarse-grained erasure channel within fixed-charge sectors via a semiclassical proposition that combines a strict exterior coarse-graining definition with GSL-compatible entropy bookkeeping and horizon-side first-law accounting. Within a fixed-charge sector, the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy increase supplies the erased-record capacity \( \Delta S_{BH}/(k_B \ln 2) \), with exact Landauer saturation when that capacity is filled. We check the supporting identities numerically across the Schwarzschild, Kerr, and Reissner-Nordström parameter spaces, and analyze robustness to the memory burden effect. The framework positions black holes as the thermodynamic counterpart to quantum measurement: measurement creates classical records by paying Landauer costs; horizons erase exterior access to those records at the quasi-static Landauer limit, while the asymptotic Hawking channel is greybody-dissipative. The manuscript is intentionally synthetic and classificatory: rather than proposing a new gravitational field equation or a single isolated theorem, it organizes several horizon regimes within one Landauer-based bookkeeping framework.

Article activity feed