Beyond one-off training: Continuing support, system stability and worker-borne costs shape electronic community health reporting in Kisii County, Kenya
Listed in
This article is not in any list yet, why not save it to one of your lists.Abstract
Kenya’s electronic community health information system (eCHIS) moves household and service data from community health promoters’ phones into the national health information system. When reporting quality falls short, the usual response is more training and competency frameworks. We tested whether user capability and one-off training explain how well the system performs for its users, or whether continuing support and system stability matter more. We also examined where quality was lost along the reporting chain. In this convergent mixed-methods cross-sectional study in Kisii County, we surveyed 343 eCHIS users in 22 facility catchments, observed five sites against a structured checklist, and interviewed 13 key informants. Hierarchical ordinal and logistic regression with facility-clustered standard errors modelled user satisfaction and perceived system consistency. Formal eCHIS training was near universal (94.5%) and was not associated with either outcome. Adding continuing support (refresher training, mentorship and technical support response time) significantly improved both models. McFadden’s pseudo-R² for consistency rose from 0.06 to 0.16. Each faster level of technical support response almost doubled the odds of reporting a consistent system (adjusted odds ratio 1.87, 95% CI 1.35-2.58). Each step up in crash frequency reduced the odds of higher satisfaction (0.60, 0.43-0.84). Digital comfort remained independently associated with both outcomes. At the observation sites, form logic secured completeness (all required fields were filled at 5 of 5 sites), but timeliness (2 of 5), consistency over time (1 of 5) and use of reports for decisions (0 of 4) failed, mostly because of synchronisation. In open-ended responses, 43.4% of respondents raised the cost of data bundles. Informants described promoters paying for connectivity and reinstalling the failing application themselves. Reporting quality depended less on what users knew than on the support around them. Competency frameworks will need matching standards for connectivity financing, support response and synchronisation monitoring.
Author Summary
Community health promoters in Kenya now record household visits on smartphones instead of paper. The aim is faster, more accurate data for planning. When the data disappoint, the usual answer is to train the promoters again. We wanted to know whether that answer fits the problem. We surveyed 343 system users in Kisii County, visited five health sites to watch the system in use, and interviewed 13 supervisors and managers. Nearly everyone had been trained, and training made no difference to how well the system worked for them. What did make a difference was how quickly technical help arrived, how often the application crashed, and whether users had ongoing refresher training and mentoring. At the sites we visited, the application made sure every form was complete. The problems came later, when records had to be uploaded over weak networks using data bundles that promoters often paid for themselves. Reports were late, sometimes duplicated, and not used for decisions. We conclude that improving community health data in Kenya means paying for connectivity, responding quickly to system failures and watching whether data actually arrive, not only training workers again.