The toll of an early bell? School start time and adolescent sleep quality in Flanders, Belgium

Read the full article See related articles

Listed in

This article is not in any list yet, why not save it to one of your lists.
Log in to save this article

Abstract

Study objectives

Adolescent sleep deprivation is a major public health concern, with insufficient and poor-quality sleep associated with adverse physical, mental and cognitive outcomes. Early school start times may contribute to sleep restriction by conflicting with the biologically delayed sleep patterns that emerge during puberty. This study examined the effect of school start times on sleep duration and sleep quality among secondary school students.

Methods

Data were obtained from the 2022 Flemish Health Behaviour in School-aged Children (HBSC) study, including 12,329 adolescents from grade 1 to 6 in 94 secondary schools in Flanders. School start times were obtained from participating schools and sleep duration and sleep quality were assessed using self-report measures. Data were analyzed using traditional statistical methods (i.e., linear regression) and debiased machine learning methods (i.e., assumption lean regression, dose response curves and modified treatment policies).

Results

No clinically meaningful effects of school start times on sleep outcomes were observed. In machine learning models, a 10-minute delay in start time was associated with non-significant changes in sleep quality (0.01 points on a 1-5 scale; 95% CI, −0.05 to 0.06) and school-day sleep duration (3.5 minutes; 95% CI, −1.0 to 8.0).

Conclusions

Within the narrow range of school start times observed in Flemish secondary schools, confidence intervals excluded clinically meaningful effects of later start times on adolescent sleep duration and sleep quality. Whether larger delays would improve sleep remains to be determined.

Statement of significance

Adolescent sleep deprivation is a major public health concern, and delaying school start times has been widely advocated as a structural strategy to improve sleep. However, evidence remains largely observational, with varying approaches to confounding control, and European data are scarce. Using causal inference methods in a population-based sample of over 12,000 Flemish secondary school students, this study showed that differences in school start times within the range currently observed were unlikely to meaningfully improve sleep duration or sleep quality. These findings suggest that modest variations in start times may be insufficient to improve adolescent sleep, highlighting the need to evaluate whether substantially later start times, while accounting for factors like commuting time, are required to generate measurable sleep benefits.

Article activity feed