A Protective Haplotype in trans Modifies Penetrance and Severity of TOR1A Dystonia
Listed in
This article is not in any list yet, why not save it to one of your lists.Abstract
Introduction
Incomplete penetrance and variable expressivity characterize autosomal dominant neurological disorders, but their genetic determinants remain largely unknown. DYT- TOR1A dystonia provides a model for investigating incomplete penetrance. We aimed to identify modifiers of disease penetrance and severity beyond the known TOR1A c.646G>C modifier.
Methods
In a prospective genotype–phenotype association study, we phenotyped Ashkenazi Jewish carriers of TOR1A c.907_909del using a prespecified five-level severity score. The primary analysis compared participants with no or minimal dystonia (scores 0–1) and severe dystonia (scores 3–4), after excluding c.646G>C carriers. Findings were assessed in an independent retrospective cohort. Sanger, exome, and short-read and long-read whole-genome sequencing were used for genotyping.
Results
The prospective cohort included 61 carriers: 21 had severe dystonia and 28 had no or minimal dystonia, six of whom carried c.646G>C. Among the 43 participants in the primary analysis, haplotype A was identified in 33 (77%) and haplotype B in eight (19%). All haplotype B carriers had no or minimal dystonia (p=0.003). Haplotype B remained associated with a milder phenotype after including 12 participants with intermediate severity (p=0.006). The retrospective cohort included 147 carriers, 16 of whom carried c.646G>C. After their exclusion, dystonia manifested in 12 (38%) of 32 participants with haplotype B and 63 (64%) of 99 without it (p=0.009). Haplotype B was also associated with lower severity scores (p=0.011). Together, c.646G>C and local haplotype status predicted the phenotype of more than two-thirds of carriers. In silico analyses linked haplotype B to lower TOR1A and higher TOR1B expression in dystonia-relevant brain regions.
Conclusion
A common local haplotype in trans to the disease-causing TOR1A variant was strongly associated with reduced penetrance and severity. These findings establish DYT- TOR1A dystonia as a model for investigating how local genetic variation contributes to incomplete penetrance in autosomal dominant neurological disorders.
