Temporal Clustering of Acute Neurological Disorders: Testing the Clinical Impression of Diagnostic “Theme Shifts”
Discuss this preprint
Start a discussion What are Sciety discussions?Listed in
This article is not in any list yet, why not save it to one of your lists.Abstract
Background
On-call clinicians frequently report the anecdotal impression of “theme shifts” during which specific acute neurological diagnoses appear to cluster. Whether such clustering reflects a statistically true and reproducible phenomenon has not been systematically investigated; the present paper examines seasonality and temporal clustering within six different acute neurological conditions.
Methods
In this retrospective, single-center cohort study, we identified all patients admitted to a tertiary neurological department between July 2016 and June 2026 with acute unilateral vestibulopathy, cerebral artery dissection, generalized epileptic seizures, primary intracerebral hemorrhage, peripheral facial nerve palsy, or transient global amnesia (TGA) (n = 2,140). Monthly and seasonal distributions were assessed using chi-squared goodness-of-fit and cosinor analysis. Short-term temporal clustering was tested by Monte Carlo permutation across time windows from 24 hours to 90 days, and endogenous cluster dynamics were characterized using Hawkes self-exciting point process modeling.
Results
Admissions for generalized epileptic seizures showed a statistically significant deviation from a uniform monthly distribution with a winter distribution (p<0.001 and q = 0.002), and a significant temporal clustering across time windows from 72 hours to 90 days (all q < 0.05). Peripheral facial nerve palsy presented significant clustering at the 90-day window (q = 0.029) and TGA at 60-day time window (q = 0.041) without seasonality; the diagnostic groups of acute unilateral vestibulopathy, cerebral artery dissection and primary intracerebral hemorrhage showed neither seasonality nor clustering after correction for multiple comparison. No diagnostic group showed clustering within a 24-hour window, statistically significant self-excitation in Hawkes process modelling, or a significant linear trend in monthly case counts over the study period.
Conclusion
The anecdotal impression of diagnostic “theme shifts” among on-call neurologists appears to have a measurable basis, although clustering is confined to specific conditions and rather on a time scale of weeks to months. Generalized epileptic seizures were the only diagnostic group that uniquely combined seasonality with temporal clustering, suggesting a shared trigger, while facial palsy and TGA showed episodic, yet non-seasonal clustering.
