Does Data Preprocessing Affect Tree-Based Super Learners? An Investigation of Ensemble Optimization and Oracle Properties in Clinical Classification

Machine learning workflows frequently incorporate data preprocessing to enhance predictive performance. However, the need for Super Learner ensembles made up only of preprocessing-invariant tree-based algorithms remains unexplored. Using three benchmark clinical classification datasets, this study examined how preprocessing affected the Super Learner’s prediction performance, learner weight distribution, and oracle behavior. The Heart Disease (207 observations), Indian Liver Patient Dataset (583 observations), and Pima Indians Diabetes (768 observations) datasets were used to create a Super Learner ensemble model that included Classification and Regression Trees (CART), Random Forest, Ranger, and Extreme Gradient Boosting (XGBoost). Models were evaluated under raw and preprocessed data conditions using repeated cross-validation. Predictive performance was assessed using the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC), Matthews correlation co-efficient (MCC), and Brier score. Learner weight allocation and Oracle Gap were compared using paired Wilcoxon signed-rank tests with Benjamini–Hochberg adjustment. Preprocessing produced negligible changes in predictive performance for the Heart Disease and Pima datasets. For the ILPD dataset, preprocessing significantly improved AUC (0.746 to 0.752; adjusted p = 0.0017) and reduced the Brier score (0.177 to 0.175; adjusted p < 0.001). Learner weights remained largely stable, although Random Forest replaced Ranger as the dominant learner for the Heart Disease dataset. Oracle Gaps remained extremely small ( < 0.002) across all datasets and did not differ significantly between preprocessing conditions. Preprocessing provides limited benefit for Super Learner ensembles composed of preprocessing-invariant learners and does not materially alter their oracle behavior. Preprocessing decisions should therefore be guided by dataset characteristics rather than adopted as a universal modelling practice.