B Cell Receptor Signaling Sets Boundaries for Selection of Broadly Neutralizing Antibody Functional Mutations

B cell signaling is required for germinal center (GC) selection and synergizes with T cell-help leading to differentiation into effector cells and a protective antibody response. Here, we studied the relationship between B cell signaling and the selection of functional mutations in a humanized mouse model of a CD4 binding-site specific HIV-1 broadly neutralizing antibody precursor. While BCR signaling increased with antigen affinity, immunization-induced frequency of a functional mutation was inversely related to affinity and favored a gain in association rate. Antigen-specific GC B cells and key mutation frequency were higher in the mid-affinity (0.5 – 5μM) than in either the higher or lower affinity group, and were consistent with the significantly higher serum neutralization titers in the mid-range group. Our studies show that BCR signaling imposes boundaries (upper/lower) for selection of antibody functional mutations and support a “Goldilocks Zone” model that defines the favored BCR signaling strength for GC selection.