Larger Pupils are Associated with Improved Visual, but not Auditory, Near-Threshold Detection

Prestimulus pupil size is associated with near-threshold detection performance in both the visual and auditory domain, a relationship that is commonly attributed to arousal. However, given that larger pupils also let more light into the eye, in the visual domain this relationship is likely also driven by optical effects. To better understand this, we investigated how pupil size, skin conductance, and electroencephalographic (EEG) measures relate to detection performance in both a visual and an auditory task. We found that larger pupils were associated with higher sensitivity in the visual condition but lower sensitivity in the auditory condition. Skin conductance was negatively related to visual sensitivity, but unrelated to auditory sensitivity. EEG power measures were not related to sensitivity in either condition, though pupil size was positively correlated with alpha and beta power. Together, these results suggest that in visual detection the relationship between pupil size and performance is driven by both arousal and optics, whereas in auditory detection the relationship is driven solely by arousal. More broadly, our findings highlight the pupil as an active and functional component of the visual system.