A Neuro-Symbolic Knowledge Graph and Large Language Model Hybrid Architecture for Multi-Modality Mental Health Counseling

Read the full article See related articles

Discuss this preprint

Start a discussion What are Sciety discussions?

Listed in

This article is not in any list yet, why not save it to one of your lists.
Log in to save this article

Abstract

Background: Depression and anxiety are managed largely between clinical visits, yet outpatient care lacks scalable, accountable mechanisms for between-visit support. Large language models converse fluently but fuse clinical reasoning with language generation in one opaque process, so they cannot reliably deliver evidence-based psychotherapy and typically operate outside clinician oversight. Objective: To evaluate C-Mind, a provider-supervised neuro-symbolic system in which a Clinical Knowledge Graph (KG) governs therapeutic decisions for a large language model across eight psychotherapy modalities. Methods: Two simulation regimes addressed eight pre-specified governance questions: a structural validation of KG routing against 117 guideline-anchored vignettes, and a governance battery using progressively disclosing LLM patient agents to evaluate decision traceability, repeatability, provenance auditability, adversarial crisis-detection robustness (277 probes), provider treatment-goal governance, and counselor technique adherence. Crisis detection was additionally validated externally against an independent, clinician-annotated corpus (CRADLE Bench). Results: The KG routed 116/117 vignettes (99.1%) to guideline-appropriate care and detected all 18 high-risk presentations, firing a therapy-suppressing hard halt on 16/18. Adversarial crisis-detection sensitivity was 96.7% and specificity 95.4% (277 probes); on external validation, the system detected 98.5% of 600 dialogues with ongoing suicidal ideation or self-harm at or before the annotator confirming turn. Decisions were 99.1% repeatable, 100% reconstructable per turn, and 100% provenance-auditable across all 354 KG nodes. Provider-set diagnosis, goals, and safety context governed behavior deterministically. Stripped of governance, the same model produced unsolicited clinical monologues on 100% of turns (vs 9% governed) and delivered diagnoses and medication advice the governed system never produced. Conclusions: A neuro-symbolic architecture achieves near-perfect guideline-appropriate routing with a governance profile, traceability, reproducibility, machine-traceable provenance, externally validated crisis detection, and deterministic provider control aligned with requirements for regulated clinical AI.

Article activity feed