Characterization of nucleus accumbens dopamine dynamics during positive and negative operant reinforcement in rats

We previously reported, using in-vivo fiber photometry, that operant responding reinforced by access to a peer (social self-administration) is associated with phasic dopamine increases in nucleus accumbens (NAc) core following lever insertion (reward-availability cue) and gradual increases preceding lever-pressing. Here, we sought to replicate these findings and determine whether dopamine signals (1) generalize to responding for high-carbohydrate palatable food, (2) show opposite patterns during negative reinforcement (shock avoidance/escape), and (3) depend on whether reinforcers are experienced alone or together.

We trained rats (n=11; 6 females) to lever-press for access to a same-sex peer (15 s/trial) and palatable food (45-mg pellet/trial), followed by shock avoidance/escape (0.18–0.26 mA). After training, we expressed the dopamine sensor GRAB-DA2m and implanted optic fibers into NAc core. We measured dopamine activity during sessions with either one- or three-reinforcers.

During social self-administration, dopamine activity showed phasic increases following lever insertion and gradual increases preceding lever-pressing; responses were moderately greater during sessions with all three reinforcers. Palatable food self-administration showed a similar pattern, but responses were approximately twofold greater during single-reinforcer sessions. During shock avoidance/escape, dopamine activity showed phasic decreases at warning onset, lever insertion, and shock onset; responses were also greater during single-reinforcer sessions.

Results suggest that NAc core dopamine signaling distinguishes positive from negative reinforcement and is modulated by reinforcer availability. Compared with single-reinforcer sessions, dopamine responses during food self-administration and shock avoidance/escape were reduced during sessions with all three reinforcers, whereas responses during social self-administration modestly increased.

Significance statement

Nucleus accumbens (NAc) dopamine is critical for processing the valence of positive reinforcers, whereas its role in negative reinforcement is less well understood. Here, we extended our prior work on operant social self-administration to determine whether these findings generalize to food reinforcement, show the opposite pattern during operant negative reinforcement (shock avoidance/escape), and depend on whether reinforcers are experienced alone or together. Results suggest that NAc core dopamine activity differentiates positive and negative reinforcement and is modulated by the presence of other available reinforcers. Specifically, dopamine responses during food self-administration and shock avoidance/escape were reduced when all three reinforcers were available together compared with when each reinforcer was experienced alone, whereas responses during social self-administration showed the opposite pattern.