Identifying the viral and epidemiological factors behind the apparent global extinction of influenza B/Yamagata

Read the full article See related articles

Discuss this preprint

Start a discussion What are Sciety discussions?

Listed in

This article is not in any list yet, why not save it to one of your lists.
Log in to save this article

Abstract

Until 2020, two lineages of the influenza B virus had co-circulated globally. The COVID-19 pandemic led to a near-absence of influenza infections. While B/Victoria reemerged in late 2021, there have been no reports of B/Yamagata since the pandemic. To investigate which epidemiological and immunological factors were primarily responsible for the extinction of B/Yamagata, we developed a global model for the two influenza B lineages. To mimic the transmission impacts of the pandemic, we implemented a transient reduction in contacts and identified parameter values that recapitulated viral coexistence dynamic before the pandemic and the qualitative post-pandemic outcomes of B/Victoria (reemergence in late 2021) and B/Yamagata (extinction). Our results suggest that, rather than immunological or evolutionary mechanisms, the extinction of B/Yamagata was mainly driven by its lower basic reproduction number making the virus particularly vulnerable during the early phase of the pandemic. Stochastic simulations of our best-fitting model suggest that B/Victoria was also close to extinction during this period. We investigate the model to assess the feasibility of B/Victoria eradication through vaccination and the potential for a sustained re-emergence of B/Yamagata in the 2026-27 flu season, thus highlighting important considerations for biosafety.

For decades, the Yamagata and Victoria lineages of the influenza B virus co-circulated globally, causing millions of infections in humans. Only Victoria reemerged after the COVID-19 pandemic. By combining mechanistic transmission modeling with worldwide influenza surveillance data, we show that Yamagata’s extinction is most consistent with a lower intrinsic transmissibility than that of the surviving Victoria lineage. Contrary to other proposed explanations, differences in cross-immunity and immune escape appear insufficient to explain the observed outcome. Our analyses further indicate that Victoria narrowly avoided extinction during the COVID-19 disruption, but now transmission of Yamagata would be sustained if the lineage were reintroduced. These results inform both influenza eradication efforts and biosafety policy.

Article activity feed