Establishing wastewater metagenomics as a quantitative pathogen monitoring tool with normalization

Wastewater metagenomic sequencing (WW-MGS) enables simultaneous detection of hundreds of pathogens, but its use for quantitative pathogen tracking has not been robustly validated. Like wastewater PCR (WW-PCR), WW-MGS is affected by biases from variable fecal dilution and sample processing, but must additionally contend with the compositional structure of sequencing data, where a taxon’s apparent abundance depends on the abundance of every other taxon in the sample. Simple summaries such as a pathogen’s fraction of total reads may therefore be poorly suited to quantitative use. We retrospectively evaluated seven normalization approaches that attempt to control for these sources of bias against a baseline of total read relative abundance, using 1,425 samples from the CASPER consortium spanning 25 U.S. sites. Each approach was compared against WW-PCR and clinical data across eight total pathogens. Among the normalization strategies we evaluated, tobamovirus markers, diet-derived plant viruses abundant in human stool, performed best. Normalizing WW-MGS data by tobamovirus-genus counts improved median site concordance for 18 of 19 pathogen and comparison-source combinations. Gains were largest for year-round-circulating SARS-CoV-2 and norovirus and smaller for sharply seasonal pathogens such as influenza and respiratory syncytial virus, where baseline concordance was already high. Tobamovirus normalization rarely degraded concordance, with median gains roughly five times larger than median losses. Tobamovirus-normalized WW-MGS reached clinical concordance comparable to targeted WW-PCR, supporting its use as a quantitative trend-monitoring tool alongside pathogen-agnostic detection.