Genetic Correlation Between Brain Imaging Phenotypes and Externalizing Behavior: A Large-Scale LDSC Analysis of UK Biobank IDPs

Externalizing has been associated with differences in brain structure and function; however, it remains unclear whether these associations reflect shared common-variant genetic influences.

Cross-trait linkage disequilibrium score regression was used to estimate genome-wide genetic correlations between externalizing genome-wide association study (GWAS) results and 3,935 brain imaging-derived phenotypes from the UK Biobank BIG40 resource. The imaging phenotypes covered structural magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), diffusion MRI, susceptibility-weighted imaging, resting-state functional MRI, and task-based functional MRI. Results were included in the primary analysis when the imaging phenotype had positive single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) heritability, a heritability Z statistic of at least 1.96, a mean GWAS chi-square statistic of at least 1.02, at least 200,000 regression SNPs, and a complete LDSC result without a fatal error. Technical imaging quality-control phenotypes were excluded from biological inference. Individual results were corrected using the Benjamini–Hochberg false discovery rate procedure. Aggregated Cauchy association tests (ACATs) were used to evaluate evidence across all imaging phenotypes and within predefined imaging categories. Statistical power, simultaneous confidence bounds, and alternative quality-control definitions were examined in sensitivity analyses.

Of the 3,935 imaging phenotypes, 3,716 produced estimable genetic correlations, 2,980 met the primary LDSC quality-control criteria, and 2,967 were classified as biological imaging phenotypes. No individual phenotype survived false discovery rate correction. The smallest unadjusted P value was 0.0005, and the minimum adjusted q value was 0.486. The distribution of genetic correlations was centered near zero, with a median genetic correlation of 0.0014 and a median absolute genetic correlation of 0.0338. ACAT provided no evidence of an aggregate association across all biological imaging phenotypes ( P = 0.302), and no predefined imaging category survived multiple-testing correction. The median minimum detectable genetic correlation at 80% power was 0.216. Bonferroni-adjusted simultaneous confidence intervals were fully contained within the interval [ − 0.30, 0.30] for 80.0% of phenotypes in the primary analysis and 88.0% under the stringent heritability quality-control definition. Broad and stringent sensitivity analyses produced the same overall conclusions.

In this study, no statistically robust evidence of genome-wide genetic correlations between externalizing and individual UK Biobank brain imaging phenotypes was found. Nevertheless, small, localized, mixed-direction, or developmentally specific genetic effects remain possible.