Multi-trophic risk from human superpredators may alter predator-prey coexistence and population dynamics

Humans are efficient and deadly predators, yet they may also interact with wildlife in non-lethal ways. This study explores how interactions with lethal and non-lethal human “superpredators” alter predator-prey dynamics using an agent-based modelling approach. Our model incorporates both the consumptive (lethal) and non-consumptive (behavioural) effects of humans, as well as of predators on prey. We explored how the replacement of apex predators by humans affects mesopredator–prey dynamics, with particular emphasis on trophic targeting and differences between lethal and non-lethal interactions. We found that human superpredators have a greater effect on model outcomes than apex predators. When superpredators consume mesopredators alone or with prey, the probability of mesopredator-prey coexistence increases to a greater extent than when apex predators consume mesopredators. In contrast, superpredators consuming only prey slightly increases overall extinction risks and reduces coexistence. Non-lethal superpredators, despite eliciting anti-predator responses in mesopredators and prey, had a negligible effect on population dynamics. Our findings demonstrate that human superpredators may functionally replace apex predators when they are lethal. However, non-lethal interactions with humans may not be as ecologically significant as lethal interactions, even when humans induce anti-predator responses.