Intermediate abundance promotes speciation when dispersal is limited

Why do some lineages diversify while others do not? This remains a central question in evolutionary ecology. A long-standing assumption, dating to Darwin and embedded in the Unified Neutral Theory of Biodiversity, holds that abundant species should speciate at higher rates. Conversely, theoretical and empirical work highlights the possibility that rare and dispersal-limited clades might be more prone to speciation. Using a birth-death-immigration model with protracted speciation in a multi-population landscape connected by limited dispersal, we show that abundance has a hump-shaped effect on probability of speciation. Our model reveals that intermediate abundance maximizes speciation probability because larger populations disperse more, swamping regional differentiation and inhibiting speciation completion, while smaller populations lack the persistence and incipient speciation needed to diversify. We find empirical support for this prediction with an analysis of data from arthropods endemic to Hawai’i, where genus-level species richness shows a significant hump-shaped relationship with mean genus abundance. These findings provide a mechanistic explanation for a nuanced relationship between abundance and diversification.