Low impact of internal stem decay on forest carbon stocks in fire-prone Pinus ponderosa forests

Large old trees are of eminent importance for organic carbon storage in forest ecosystems and thus play a role in mitigating climate change. Such trees also have an increased risk of internal stem decay and tree cavity formation, which promotes biodiversity, but complicates the prediction of their biomass and carbon stocks, which is usually done from stem diameter and tree height data applying allometric biomass functions. Since the extent of internal stem decay is known to vary widely between different forest ecosystems and data from moist temperate forests exhibited low significance of internal stem decay, we studied dry, frequently fire-exposed Pinus ponderosa forests in central Oregon to capture the other climatic extreme of temperate forests. We hypothesized high significance of internal stem decay for stand aboveground tree biomass, as we assumed widespread stem injury from fire. In addition, we tested the hypothesis that far more than the largest 1% of trees are necessary for 50% stand biomass, as this hypothesis is found in the literature, but has been challenged in other studies. We found low biomass loss due to internal stem decay by only ca. 1% suggesting that also for fire-prone temperate forests of western North America, biomass estimates based on allometric regression are reliable. The ‘1% largest trees-50% stand aboveground biomass’ hypothesis has to be rejection for our forests as long as only trees of a size are included that noteworthily contribute to stand biomass. This metrics strongly depends on regeneration density, which is not relevant for stand biomass.