Neuroanatomical differences in early bilingual and monolingual children

Prior studies have reported inconsistent results for neuroanatomical differences between early bilinguals and monolinguals. These studies primarily measured gray matter volume (GMV), involved small samples, and prioritized adults. Few studies of early bilinguals have measured cortical thickness (CT), which offers more anatomical specificity. It remains unclear whether results derived from differing metrics and approaches (e.g., vertex-versus parcel-wise analyses) converge. Using data from the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development ^SM (ABCD) Study, we compared neuroanatomy between large groups of early cultural Spanish-English bilingual and English monolingual children (N = 1,209) matched on age, pubertal status, sex, handedness, socioeconomic status (SES), and nonverbal reasoning. Whole-brain voxel-based morphometry revealed areas of greater and of lesser GMV in bilinguals than monolinguals across all lobes. Vertex-wise CT analyses similarly identified widespread differences, with bilinguals showing areas of both thicker and thinner cortex. We contextualized these findings with parcel-wise CT analyses (average CT values), utilizing two atlases of differing spatial granularity. Parcel-wise results showed good correspondence with vertex-wise findings when implementing the more fine-grained atlas (Destrieux), but use of the coarser atlas (Desikan-Killiany) provided results that led to different conclusions. Finally, we tested for interaction effects between bilingualism and SES on CT and found several regions where differences between bilinguals and monolinguals in CT were modulated by SES. Together, these findings indicate that early bilingualism is associated with extensive neuroanatomical differences relative to monolinguals during childhood, and that these results can vary as a function of neuroanatomical metric, analysis approach, atlas granularity, and SES.