sctrial: Participant-Level Differential Analysis for Longitudinal Single-Cell Experiments

Read the full article See related articles

Discuss this preprint

Start a discussion What are Sciety discussions?

Listed in

This article is not in any list yet, why not save it to one of your lists.
Log in to save this article

Abstract

Longitudinal single-cell RNA sequencing studies in clinical trials and translational cohorts offer a powerful view of treatment response, disease progression, and cellular dynamics, but their hierarchical structure poses a major inferential challenge: thousands of cells are measured within the same participants across repeated time points, whereas the participant, not the cell, is the true unit of biological replication. Conventional cell-level workflows can therefore yield inflated significance and misleading confidence in reported associations. Here, we present sctrial , an open source analytical framework for repeated-measures single-cell studies that uses design-specific participant-level estimands, including difference-in-differences for two-group longitudinal comparisons, and small-cluster-aware uncertainty quantification. In simulation benchmarks using a hierarchical gamma-Poisson generative model, sctrial maintained well-calibrated error rates in mixed-signal gene panels where established multi-subject methods showed inflated false positive rates among unaffected genes. We applied sctrial to five independent datasets spanning melanoma immunotherapy, COVID-19 severity, BNT162b2 vaccination, AML chemotherapy, and CAR-T therapy. Across these studies, sctrial identified immune programs whose direction and magnitude differed across therapeutic and disease contexts, while benchmarking analyses showed that many associations highlighted by conventional cell-level workflows were attenuated or no longer supported when inference was performed at the participant level. These analyses illustrate how participant-aware inference can reduce pseudoreplication-driven signal inflation and provide a more rigorous basis for interpreting longitudinal single-cell data. sctrial enables reproducible participant-level analysis of longitudinal single-cell experiments and facilitates more reliable biological interpretation in translational and clinical studies. The software is implemented in Python and compatible the AnnData/scverse ecosystem.

Article activity feed