Life Cycle and Circularity: The Assessment of Conventional and Additive Manufacturing Injection Molds

The transition to a circular economy requires assessment tools that capture not only the environmental and economic performance of products but also their circular design, functionality, and durability. While Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) and Life Cycle Costing (LCC) are widely used, they alone do not capture modularity, reparability, reuse potential, or product lifespan. This study introduces a novel, integrated framework combining LCA, LCC, and product-level circularity indicators to provide a holistic evaluation of sustainability and circularity. In this study, two types of injection molds for plastic part production are compared: a conventionally manufactured mold and an additively manufactured metal mold produced by Laser Powder Bed Fusion (L-PBF) technology. The comparison integrates Life Cycle Assessment (LCA), Life Cycle Costing (LCC), and a set of micro-circularity indicators, including the Material Circularity Indicator (MCI), Recycling Desirability Index (RDI), circular design guidelines (CDG), Disassembly Effort Index (DEI), longevity indicator (LI), and Circular Economy Indicator Prototype (CEIP). Results show that the AM mold exhibits lower environmental impacts across almost all categories, while its slightly higher initial cost is largely offset by reduced indirect costs over the product lifecycle. Micro-circularity indicators reveal that the AM mold achieves higher material circularity and better circular design performance (MCI, CDG, CEIP) but shows only minor improvements in disassembly and recyclability (DEI, RDI) and lower longevity (LI) compared to the conventional mold, highlighting potential limitations for remanufacturing and end-of-life recovery. The novelty of this study lies in the integrated application of LCA, LCC, and multiple micro-circularity indicators, providing an operational framework for evaluating circular design, reparability, and durability in additive manufacturing and enabling informed, holistic decision-making for truly circular products.