Toward Intelligent Underwater Acoustic Systems: Systematic Insights into Channel Estimation and Modulation Methods

Underwater acoustic (UWA) communication supports many critical applications but still faces several physical-layer signal processing challenges. In response, recent advances in machine learning (ML) and deep learning (DL) offer promising solutions to improve signal detection, modulation adaptability, and classification accuracy. These developments highlight the need for a systematic evaluation to compare various ML/DL models and assess their performance across diverse underwater conditions. However, most existing reviews on ML/DL-based UWA communication focus on isolated approaches rather than integrated system-level perspectives, which limits cross-domain insights and reduces their relevance to practical underwater deployments. Consequently, this systematic literature review (SLR) synthesizes 43 studies (2020–2025) on ML and DL approaches for UWA communication, covering channel estimation, adaptive modulation, and modulation recognition across both single- and multi-carrier systems. The findings reveal that models such as convolutional neural networks (CNNs), long short-term memory networks (LSTMs), and generative adversarial networks (GANs) enhance channel estimation performance, achieving error reductions and bit error rate (BER) gains ranging from 10−3 to 10−6. Adaptive modulation techniques incorporating support vector machines (SVMs), CNNs, and reinforcement learning (RL) attain classification accuracies exceeding 98% and throughput improvements of up to 25%. For modulation recognition, architectures like sequence CNNs, residual networks, and hybrid convolutional–recurrent models achieve up to 99.38% accuracy with latency below 10 ms. These performance metrics underscore the viability of ML/DL-based solutions in optimizing physical-layer tasks for real-world UWA deployments. Finally, the SLR identifies key challenges in UWA communication, including high complexity, limited data, fragmented performance metrics, deployment realities, energy constraints and poor scalability. It also outlines future directions like lightweight models, physics-informed learning, advanced RL strategies, intelligent resource allocation, and robust feature fusion to build reliable and intelligent underwater systems.