MEDIATED AGENCY: A FRAMEWORK FOR CREATIVE SELF-EFFICACY IN HUMAN-AI COLLABORATION
Discuss this preprint
Start a discussion What are Sciety discussions?Listed in
This article is not in any list yet, why not save it to one of your lists.Abstract
Generative AI is reshaping creative practice by expanding what individuals can produce while complicating how effort, authorship, and mastery are understood. This article introduces mediated agency as a framework for explaining how human–AI collaboration reshapes creative self-efficacy and the horizons of creative possibility. Mediated agency refers to the experience of acting creatively when intention, process, and outcome are co-produced by human and algorithmic elements, producing new forms of attribution ambiguity, opacity, and uneven control. Extending Bandura’s account of self-efficacy, the framework reconceptualizes mastery experiences, vicarious learning, social persuasion, and affective states as relational processes unfolding within sociotechnical systems and examines how they are interpreted across three dimensions: control over process, authorship and attribution, and creative identity. The article differentiates mediated agency from co-creativity, human-centered AI, and technology adoption perspectives, and presents propositions and design principles for studying and supporting creative self-efficacy in AI-mediated contexts. Sustaining creative confidence requires attending not only to what AI enables people to produce but to how mediation shapes their experience of contribution, capability, and future creative possibility.