I’m Trying to Read Here! How Does Irrelevant Speech Affect How You Read?

Read the full article See related articles

Listed in

This article is not in any list yet, why not save it to one of your lists.
Log in to save this article

Abstract

Purpose: Reading involves a remarkable coordination of perceptual and linguistic processes. This coordination is reflected by a close coupling between reading eye movements and lexical properties of words, such as word frequency and predictability, as well as morpho-syntactic and semantic regularities. Yet, reading is also subject to interference, and a common source of interference is when others are speaking nearby. Then, how does irrelevant speech affect reading as reflected in eye movements? Method: Fifty-nine participants (mean age: 19, 25 females, 34 males, primary language: English) read passages from the PROVO corpus (Luke & Christianson, 2018) under intelligible irrelevant speech or silence, with eye movements recorded. We investigated how irrelevant speech influences the link between eye movements and several indicators of lexical difficulty: word frequency, cloze probability (exact-word predictability), large-language-model-generated surprisal, morpho-syntactic predictability (part-of-speech and inflection), and semantic predictability (general meaning). Results: Relationships between these lexical variables and eye movements remained robust during first-pass reading and were unaffected by irrelevant speech, suggesting intact lexical and syntactic processing during early stages of reading. However, disruption emerged in later eye-movement measures (i.e., total viewing time), where low-frequency and semantically unpredictable words prompted increased re-reading under irrelevant speech. Conclusion: These results indicate that intelligible irrelevant speech selectively interferes with post-lexical, higher-order semantic integration. The increased re-reading of rare and semantically unpredictable words suggests that readers compensate by revisiting these words to repair difficulties in integrating their meanings into a coherent understanding of the text.

Article activity feed