A Critical Test of Signal Detection Theory in Visual Working Memory
Listed in
This article is not in any list yet, why not save it to one of your lists.Abstract
Signal detection theory (SDT) provides a prominent framework for modelling recognition memory judgments. Although specific SDT model variants have been extensively tested in working memory, fundamental properties like random-scale representation and receiver operating characteristic (ROC) symmetry have not been critically examined in this domain. Here, we tested these core assumptions across two experiments using multi-alternative forced-choice tasks. In Experiment 1 (N = 123), participants viewed displays of eight images and made recognition judgments among varying numbers of alternatives. Results demonstrated that these decisions satisfied theoretical constraints required by random-scale representations, validating a key assumption of the broader SDT framework. In Experiment 2 (N = 304), we directly tested ROC symmetry by comparing performance between standard recognition tasks and a modified version where participants selected novel rather than studied items. Against common assumption, results provided clear evidence for ROC asymmetry, mirroring patterns previously observed in long-term memory. Together, these findings validate fundamental SDT properties in visual working memory and suggest important commonalities across mnemonic faculties.