Regression Algorithms in Normative Modeling for Neuroimaging

Read the full article

Discuss this preprint

Start a discussion What are Sciety discussions?

Listed in

This article is not in any list yet, why not save it to one of your lists.
Log in to save this article

Abstract

Normative modeling constructs population-level reference trajectories of brain descriptive parameters against clinical covariates, enabling individual-level deviation detection through z-scores. The regression algorithm at its core --- estimating both the conditional mean and the conditional variance --- sets a ceiling on the accuracy of every downstream z-score. As neuroimaging enters the big-data era, regression methods face escalating demands in computational scalability, in robustness to outliers, and in geometric fidelity for non-Euclidean descriptors on Riemannian manifolds. This review provides a systematic survey of regression algorithms within the normative-modeling framework, covering parametric, semiparametric, nonparametric, Bayesian, and deep-learning approaches. To enable horizontal comparison rather than family-by-family enumeration, we organize the exposition around three challenge axes --- scalability, robustness, and geometry --- and place four representative normative methods on a common location--scale template that makes explicit how their differing regression mechanics propagate into z-score quality. Building on this framework, a reproducible simulation benchmark on synthetic heteroscedastic data contrasts seven regression algorithms in statistical quality and outlier resilience, complemented by a 2-D real-data case study on the HarMNqEEG Cuba1990 healthy reference, from which practical method-selection guidance emerges. We further detail M-estimation-based robust extensions and intrinsic regression on symmetric positive-definite manifolds, before closing with open questions on adaptive smoothing-parameter selection, higher-order moment estimation, and non-Euclidean scalability. Together, these threads position the regression algorithm as a first-class design choice in normative modeling --- one whose principled treatment is essential for translating population-scale neuroimaging into reliable individual-level clinical inference.

Article activity feed