Impact of the Kohn-Sham Delocalization Error on Organic Conjugated π Systems

This study investigates the extent of π-orbital delocalization in Kohn-Sham (KS) density functional calculations in relation to the KS delocalization error (DE) for different classes of π-conjugated organic molecules. The set of molecules includes conjugated polyenes,Hückel aromatic cyclic polyenes, cyanines, and merocyanines. The DE as probed by the curvature of the energy E(N) as a function of the electron number N in fractional-electron calculations causes corresponding trends in the extent of the delocalization of the π-orbitals when the latter are chosen to be localized. The DE is assessed in comparison with calculations based on 'optimally tuned' functionals with range-separated exchange (OT-RSH) and varying fractions of exact exchange in the short-range limit of the interelectronic separation. The OT-RSH calculations produce negligible E(N) curvature for all tested systems. An interpolation for E(N) proposed in the literature gives, which only requires integer-N calculations, gives excellent agreement with the fractional-N KS data, with the exception of the longer-chain merocyanines in conjunction with Hartree-Fock calculations. The breakdown of the fractional-electron calculations for the latter cases goes along with a triplet instability of the closed-shell singlet electronic structures.