Australian Senecio macrocarpus and S. squarrosus were suggested as apomictic but are fully sexual: evidence from flow cytometric seed screening analyses

Asexual seed reproduction, apomixis, is a relatively rare reproductive strategy in angiosperms. Its rarity is probably due to evolutionary constraints that require full and synchronous expression of all the steps that modify the ancestral sexual pathway. Therefore, the documentation of any new occurrence of apomixis, especially in taxonomic groups with no previous report, should be based on thorough and solid evidence. Here we correct the report of apomictic reproduction in two endemic hexaploid species of Senecio from Australia. Based on either excess or deficiency of expected heterozygosity across loci, over-representation of several multilocus genotypes, and segregation analysis assessed using microsatellite markers, it was suggested that apomixis together with selfing could explain the observed patterns of genetic variation in perennial S. macrocarpus and annual S. squarrosus . We used flow cytometric seed screening analyses to verify the mode of reproduction of several widespread multilocus genotypes that are considered to be apomictic. These analyses revealed that all seed progeny arose by the sexual pathway, as they exhibited a constant 3:2 endosperm to embryo ploidy ratio, typical of double fertilization of a reduced embryo sac by two reduced sperm cells. Therefore, both species reproduce sexually. We suggest that the unusual genetic patterns in both allopolyploids are caused by originally low variation in the parental species, which probably also reproduce by selfing, disomic inheritance and probably also the presence of null alleles. We call for a more careful and critical interpretation of the patterns obtained, taking into account all aspects related to apomictic reproduction.