The Effects of an Individual-Level Strategy on Adoption and Completion of Trauma-Focused Cognitive Behavioral Therapy in Schools: Results from a Hybrid Type 2 Randomized Trial

Read the full article See related articles

Listed in

This article is not in any list yet, why not save it to one of your lists.
Log in to save this article

Abstract

Background School-based mental health (SBMH) providers face challenges adopting high-quality evidence-based practices (EBPs) like Trauma-Focused Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (TF-CBT). Individual-level factors (e.g., attitudes) are key implementation determinants, but little is known about how strategies targeting these mechanisms affect not only whether, but when, providers implement EBPs. Beliefs and Attitudes for Successful Implementation in Schools (BASIS) is a theory-driven, evidence-based strategy targeting individual-level mechanisms (e.g., attitudes, self-efficacy). This study compared BASIS to an attention control (AC) condition on SBMH providers’ implementation mechanisms, TF-CBT adoption and completion, and their pace. Methods In a hybrid type 2 effectiveness-implementation randomized trial, 92 SBMH providers received BASIS or AC alongside TF-CBT training and consultation. Implementation mechanisms and outcomes (screener adoption, TF-CBT adoption, and TF-CBT completion with at least one student) were assessed at 13 timepoints across pre-implementation (T0-T5), active implementation (T6-T9), and sustainment (T10-T12). Mechanisms were analyzed using mixed-effects models; adoption/completion outcomes and pacing were evaluated using time-to-event analyses, chi-square tests, and Mann-Whitney U tests. We also explored whether mechanisms predicted pacing using a non-parametric GLM gamma log link. Results BASIS had minimal impact on hypothesized mechanisms but significant effects on some adoption pacing. BASIS providers had higher injunctive ( p =.015) and descriptive ( p =.013) norms than AC overall, though norms did not differ by phase (all p -values>.05). Conditions did not differ in attitudes or self-efficacy over time (all p -values>.05). Implementation intentions fluctuated, decreasing during active implementation ( p <.001) and increasing in sustainment ( p =.033). By the end of active implementation, BASIS providers were more likely to have administered a screener (85% vs. 62.5%; p =.022) and marginally more likely to have adopted TF-CBT (80% vs. 60%; p =.051) but did not differ from AC in TF-CBT completion (27.5% vs. 30%; p =.805). Contrary to hypotheses, providers with more positive attitudes and self-efficacy post-TF-CBT training took longer to administer their first screener, regardless of condition. Conclusions Schools increase youth access to mental health services, but EBPs must be implemented quickly to fit a school year’s time constraints. BASIS accelerated screener adoption, but further research is needed on its potential to influence TF-CBT adoption and completion pacing. Implementation mechanisms may shift across the implementation timeline, and strategies are needed to align with key implementation windows. Trial registration ClinicalTrials.gov ID NCT04451161. Registered on 6/26/2020.

Article activity feed