Universal Suffering Units (USU): A Calibrated Additive Unit of Experienced Suffering

Read the full article See related articles

Discuss this preprint

Start a discussion What are Sciety discussions?

Listed in

This article is not in any list yet, why not save it to one of your lists.
Log in to save this article

Abstract

We present the Universal Suffering Unit (USU), a calibrated, additive unit of experienced suffering that scales with intensity, duration, and affected population, enabling aggregation across people, regions or countries, and time. We define USU as k * sum I^p * Δt, where I is a 0–10 intensity rating, p >= 1 is an exponent that modestly up-weights high intensities, and k is a calibration constant. We calibrate the unit so that a reference trajectory of renal colic (kidney-stone pain) equals 1.0 USU, propose a simple rule for co-occurring harms, and recommend reporting medians with 90% uncertainty intervals from Monte Carlo simulations. Using publicly available data, we illustrate the framework with two examples: dengue in Brazil (epidemiological weeks 1–23 of 2024) and flood-related displacement in Rio Grande do Sul, plus a year-over-year dengue comparison and a sensitivity analysis over p in {1.0, 1.25, 1.5}. These illustrations show how large numbers of moderate episodes and smaller numbers of longer, disruptive episodes can be expressed on a common experiential scale, while remaining interpretable via an anchor ladder. We discuss validation strategies, highlight ethical guardrails and misuse risks, and argue that USU is best used alongside DALY/QALY and routine operational indicators as a decision-support tool for comparing heterogeneous harms, rather than as a stand-alone welfare metric.

Article activity feed