Seven Thousand Felt Earthquakes in Oklahoma and Kansas Can Be Confidently Traced Back to Oil and Gas Activities

The seismicity levels in Oklahoma and southern Kansas have increased dramatically over the last 15 years. Past studies have identified the massive disposal of wastewater co-produced during oil and gas extraction as the driving force behind some earthquake clusters, with a small number of events directly linked to hydraulic fracturing (HF) stimulations. The present investigation is the first one to examine the role both of these activities played throughout the two states, under the same framework. Our findings confirm that wastewater disposal is the main causal factor, while also identifying several previously undocumented clusters of seismicity that were triggered by HF. We were able to identify areas where both causal factors spatially coincide, even though they act at distinct depth intervals. Overall, oil and gas operations are probabilistically linked at high confidence levels with more than 7000 felt earthquakes (M ≥ 2.5), including 46 events with M ≥ 4.0 and 4 events with M ≥ 5. Our analysis utilized newly compiled regional earthquake catalogs and established physics-based principles. It first hindcasts the seismicity rates after 2012 on a spatial grid using either real or randomized HF and wastewater data as the input, and then compares them against the null hypothesis of purely tectonic loading. In the end, each block is assigned a p-value, reflecting the statistical confidence in its causal association with either HF stimulations or wastewater disposal.