Penalty Strategies in Semiparametric Regression Models

This study includes a comprehensive evaluation of six penalty estimation strategies for partially linear models (PLRMs), focusing on their performance in the presence of multicollinearity and their ability to handle both parametric and nonparametric components. The methods under consideration include Ridge regression, Lasso, Adaptive Lasso (aLasso), smoothly clipped absolute deviation (SCAD), ElasticNet, and minimax concave penalty (MCP). In addition to these established methods, we also incorporate Stein-type shrinkage estimation techniques that are standard and positive shrinkage, and assess their effectiveness in this context. To estimate the PLRMs, we considered a kernel smoothing technique grounded in penalized least squares. Our investigation involves a theoretical analysis of the estimators' asymptotic properties and a detailed simulation study designed to compare their performance under a variety of conditions, including different sample sizes, numbers of predictors, and levels of multicollinearity. The simulation results reveal that aLasso and shrinkage estimators, particularly the positive shrinkage estimator, consistently outperform the other methods in terms of Mean Squared Error (MSE) relative efficiencies (RE), especially when the sample size is small, and multicollinearity is high. Furthermore, we present a real data analysis using the Hitters dataset to demonstrate the applicability of these methods in a practical setting. The results of the real data analysis align with the simulation findings, highlighting the superior predictive accuracy of aLasso and the shrinkage estimators in the presence of multicollinearity. The findings of this study offer valuable insights into the strengths and limitations of these penalty and shrinkage strategies, guiding their application in future research and practice involving semiparametric regression.