Consensus-Based Definitions for Vocal Biomarkers: The International VOCAL Initiative
Discuss this preprint
Start a discussion What are Sciety discussions?Listed in
This article is not in any list yet, why not save it to one of your lists.Abstract
Importance
Voice-based health technologies are growing rapidly, but they lack standardized terminology, which hinders interdisciplinary collaboration, research quality, and clinical translation.
Objective
The objective of this work is to develop universally accepted definitions in the rapidly evolving field of vocal biomarkers, as part of the VOCAL ( V ocal Biomarker Guidelines for O ntology, C lassification, A pplication, and L ogistics) initiative, a structured, international consensus-based framework that aims to provide standards, and guidelines.
Design
VOCAL is a rigorous, international, multi-stage consensus-building study conducted in 2024-2025.
Setting
Multi-institutional collaboration between representatives from the Bridge2AI-Voice Consortium (North America) and the eVoiceNet Network (European Union), culminating in an in-person workshop at the 2025 Bridge2AI Voice Symposium.
Participants
A group of 24 international experts in medicine, clinical research, speech and language, audio signal processing, statistics, methodology, regulation, ethics.
Methods
VOCAL’s iterative process involved five rounds of review, feedback, and an in-person workshop at the international 2025 Bridge2AI Voice Symposium, ensuring the incorporation of diverse perspectives and achieving a robust agreement on the proposed definitions.
Main outcomes and measures
Consensus-based definitions for vocal biomarkers, spanning from broad concepts (biomarker, digital biomarker, vocal biomarker) to domain-specific measures (cardio-respiratory acoustic, voice, speech/articulatory, cognitive/language).
Results
A hierarchical continuum model of vocal biomarkers was established. We first distinguished between the concepts of vocal measures and vocal biomarkers. We then defined terms from broad, overarching concepts (Level 0: Biomarker, Digital Biomarker, Vocal Biomarker) to more specific physiological and cognitive domains (Level 1: Cardio-Respiratory Acoustic; Level 2: Voice; Level 3: Speech/Articulatory; Level 4: Cognitive/Language, including linguistic and paralinguistic subtypes).
Conclusions and Relevance
This work provides a shared vocabulary that is essential for fostering communication through interdisciplinary collaboration, improving the quality and efficiency of research and development, and ensuring the ethical, reliable, and scalable deployment of future voice-based health technologies. It lays foundational groundwork for upcoming guidelines and standards, which are crucial for advancing the field of vocal biomarkers into widespread clinical utility.
Key points
Question
Can we establish an international consensus on the definitions related to vocal biomarkers?
Findings
Through a multi-stage international consensus process involving expert representatives from the Bridge2AI-Voice Consortium and eVoiceNet Network, a hierarchical model of vocal biomarkers was developed, defining terms from broad concepts (biomarker, digital biomarker, vocal biomarker) to specific physiological and cognitive domains (cardio-respiratory acoustic, voice, speech/articulatory, cognitive/language).
Meaning
Standardized definitions for vocal biomarkers provide an essential shared vocabulary for interdisciplinary collaboration and lay the foundational groundwork for future guidelines needed to advance the implementation of voice-based health technologies into clinical practice and clinical research.
