Comparing the genetic diversity of two threatened Rhyticeros hornbill species with contrasting geographic range sizes

Island endemics exhibit low genetic diversity due to founder effects and geographical isolation, increasing their vulnerability to inbreeding depression. The Narcondam Hornbill ( Rhyticeros narcondami ), restricted to the 6.8 km ² Narcondam island in the Andaman archipelago, has the smallest range size among hornbills, a globally threatened group of birds. We compared the genetic diversity of the Narcondam Hornbill with the Wreathed Hornbill ( Rhyticeros undulatus ) distributed from the Eastern Himalaya to Bali. We generated DNA sequences for four mitochondrial markers ; Cytochrome B (Cytb), cytochrome c oxidase subunit I (COI), NADH dehydrogenase subunit 2 (ND2) and displacement loop (D-loop) regions) from 14 Narcondam Hornbill faecal samples and for three markers (Cytb, COI and ND2) from 19 Wreathed Hornbill tissue samples from north-east India. Our results suggest markedly lower genetic diversity in the island endemic Narcondam Hornbill compared to the Wreathed Hornbill. Specifically, Cytb and COI showed no genetic variation in the island endemic, compared to three to five haplotypes in the Wreathed Hornbills. In the ND2 region, Narcondam Hornbills showed seven haplotypes among 13 samples compared to the Wreathed Hornbill’s six haplotypes among eight samples. The observed genetic diversity in the D-loop in the Narcondam Hornbill was lower than other island-endemic hornbill species in the Philippines. The extremely low genetic diversity in the Narcondam Hornbill likely stems from a small founder population and/or past hunting pressures that reduced its numbers to approximately 30% of its current population of 1000 birds, rendering the Narcondam Hornbill susceptible to environmental and human-driven changes.