Evaluation of LiDAR-based Canopy Trait Estimation in Midwestern Row Crops
Discuss this preprint
Start a discussion What are Sciety discussions?Listed in
This article is not in any list yet, why not save it to one of your lists.Abstract
Stand count, the number of plants per unit ground area, and leaf area index (LAI), the ratio of leaf area to ground area, are critical traits for crop research but are traditionally measured using labor-intensive methods. While new sensing technologies are being developed, quantifying improvement in measurement efficiency and data quality, relative to traditional techniques, is lacking. In this study, we use LiDAR to generate 3D scans of corn and soybean plots and evaluate two computational methods: a gap fraction approach to estimate LAI and a persistent homology algorithm to estimate stand count by detecting structural peaks in the canopy. Validation experiments and statistical comparisons of bias and variance demonstrate that LiDAR-derived LAI estimates in corn are comparable in quality to those from established instruments. However, in soybean, the LiDAR method performs poorly, likely due to dense canopies limiting light penetration and structural differentiation. Stand count estimations in corn closely match manual counts, with the added benefit of full-plot coverage and significantly faster data collection. In soybean, stand count estimates are unreliable under dense canopy conditions. These results offer practical guidance for the use of LiDAR in field phenotyping and highlight both its current capabilities and limitations. While a trade-off between speed and precision remains, particularly in high-density canopies, LiDAR’s scalability and multi-trait potential make it a promising tool for high-throughput breeding programs. Continued improvements in LiDAR hardware and algorithm design may further enhance measurement accuracy and extend applicability across crops and growth stages.
