Co-evolved Partners of Immunity: A Trait-Based Map of Human Keystone Organisms

Persistent human-adapted microbes can act as immunological “keystones,” organizing host defense across tissues and shaping vulnerability under immune perturbation. Here we operationalize keystone organisms as pathogens whose containment requires coordinated engagement of multiple immune arms and whose residence is structured across anatomical niches. Using 18 curated immunological and evolutionary traits across 43 organisms, unsupervised analyses resolved four reproducible archetypes and identified a compact keystone set dominated by persistent herpesviruses and Mycobacterium tuberculosis . We then translated the clinical literature into a pathogen × immune-perturbation × niche tensor capturing where and when each organism emerges under defined immune deficits. We quantified “diagnostic breadth” with two complementary summaries: immune breadth (diversity of perturbations associated with emergence) and niche breadth (diversity of anatomical sites). Clinical emergence patterns perfectly separated trait-defined keystones from all other organisms and highlighted expanded niche breadth as the primary discriminator, whereas immune breadth showed no significant group separation. Finally, a mechanistic model integrating barrier disruption, latent reservoir activation, and tissue-resident immune control predicted clinical emergence from first principles—without fitting parameters to individual pathogens—and ranked true emergences 2.9-fold above chance among its highest-confidence predictions. Together, these results link evolutionary adaptation to clinically readable patterns of reactivation, motivate archetype-aware surveillance under immunosuppression, and provide a framework for immunogen design that prioritizes conserved, functionally constrained targets.