Cost and cost-effectiveness of tongue swab-based molecular testing for tuberculosis in the Philippines, Uganda, Vietnam, and Zambia
Discuss this preprint
Start a discussion What are Sciety discussions?Listed in
This article is not in any list yet, why not save it to one of your lists.Abstract
Background
Tongue swabs (TS) offer a promising alternative to sputum-based molecular testing for tuberculosis. However, the health and cost implications of TS-based testing remain poorly understood. As part of the Tongue Swab Yield (TSwaY) study, we aimed to assess the cost and cost-effectiveness of integrating TS-based testing using MiniDock MTB Test (Guangzhou Pluslife Biotech, China), a novel rapid molecular assay, into primary healthcare in four high-burden countries.
Methods
We collected cost data from primary healthcare facilities in the Philippines, Uganda, Vietnam, and Zambia. We estimated incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICERs) for (1) TS MiniDock MTB Test as a replacement for sputum Xpert Ultra, and (2) combined testing in which TS MiniDock MTB Test is used for sputum-scarce people and those with negative/indeterminate sputum results. ICERs were estimated with respect to the current sputum Xpert Ultra strategy. Net monetary benefits (NMB) were estimated across willingness-to-pay (WTP) thresholds. Best estimates were based on observed diagnostic yield, with 95% uncertainty intervals (95%UI) derived from probabilistic simulation.
Findings
Among 1,370 participants, sputum Xpert Ultra resulted in 67 (95%UI: 46–89) bacteriologically confirmed tuberculosis diagnoses at an estimated cost of USD 507 per diagnosis. Replacing sputum Xpert Ultra with TS MiniDock MTB Test reduced total costs but yielded fewer diagnoses (62 [95%UI: 42–83]). The combined testing strategy led to 22 (95%UI: 13–30) additional diagnoses at an incremental cost of USD 742 (95%UI: 514–1,267) per additional diagnosis and yielded the highest NMB at WTP thresholds above USD 1,077. Limiting TS MiniDock MTB Test to sputum-scarce individuals yielded 7 (95%UI: 2–13) additional diagnoses at an incremental cost of USD 196 (95%UI: 106–695) per additional diagnosis.
Interpretation
Combining sputum- and TS-based molecular testing can improve tuberculosis detection at reasonable additional cost. Our findings support integrating TS MiniDock MTB Test into diagnostic algorithms in high-burden settings.
Funding
Gates Foundation.
